Round fifteen selections

Manly Sea Eagles vs Wests Tigers – Friday night – Brookvale Oval

Slightly odd that the free-to-air Friday night fixture this round sees the team running last taking on the team running 13th. And slightly odd that the team running last are a short-priced favourite - especially on the back of an impressive display by the Tigers last weekend. Daly Cherry-Evans (probably) backs up for the Sea Eagles. Aaron Woods (probably) backs up for the Tigers. Robbie Farah is nowhere to be seen. The venue sways my verdict here but I'm tipping the outcome with my usual lack of Friday night confidence. I do worry about the Sea Eagles pack, but I'll cross my fingers and hope they keep it together. The Tigers forwards were tremendous against the Bunnies, but Woods may have some of the gusto taken out of his sails given the quick turnaround and the flight back from Melbourne. At $1.40 backing the Sea Eagles should be a criminal offence. Those that back the Tigers with the handicap start should get a run for their money. The Sea Eagles to squeak home.

Verdict – Sea Eagles by 2

Result - Sea Eagles 30 defeated Tigers 20

Canberra Raiders vs North Queensland Cowboys – Saturday afternoon – GIO Stadium

The Cowboys jag a daytime slot in Canberra which is a small blessing - by nightfall the temperature will be minus something. The Raiders have had two weeks to prepare for this game, their line-up is unchanged, free of Origin interruption and they get to play at home. Both Cowboys props and both Cowboys halves are backing up from Wednesday - if they back up at all (Thurston will have a pretty funny looking right eye if he does). If the Raiders don't throw ball-runners at the right edge defence of the Cowboys I'll be very surprised. Memo to Morgan and O'Neill - steel yourselves for an onslaught. If you like those bets Coach puts on try and find a reasonable price for Jarrod Croker to pick up a four-pointer. Surely. Surely.

Verdict – Raiders by 2

Result - Cowboys 21 defeated Raiders 20

Gold Coast Titans vs New Zealand Warriors – Saturday night – CBus Super Stadium

Anyone who spends any amount of time on the Gold Coast will know that the Warriors will get their fair share of the crowd support on Saturday night. The Warriors have a 50/50 all-time record on the Gold Coast and their away record this season is pretty similar (3 from 7). In round eight these sides met in New Zealand and the Titans prevailed (32-28) and that is probably more important than any historical record. Notably a fair number of the Titans that played in that last clash won't be here this time (Bird, Zillman, Elgey, Falloon).  That worries me a little, but assuming Myles plays this line-up is stronger than the one that ran away from the Bulldogs last week. That's probably good enough. I don't mind Hoffman in the halves either - he's under-rated by everyone bar me and the footballers that play alongside him.

Verdict – Titans by 2

Result - Warriors 36 defeated Titans 14

Canterbury Bulldogs vs Penrith Panthers – Saturday night – ANZ Stadium

Bulldogs coach Des Hasler has never been one to take a backward step on or off the paddock. As if to reiterate his point about the impact of the State of Origin series on the NRL, he has not named any of his Origin players this weekend. None of them, not even on an extended 12 man bench. The point is well made but it does make it hard for us to pick a winner. With the teams named as is I think the Panthers are good things, but the current betting market (Penrith paying $2.75) tells me to expect some last minute team changes. If Des didn't get fined last week he might get pinged this time around. Tipping winners on a Wednesday isn't easy at the best of times, but this game is quite a challenge. Up until this point my approach has been to play the cards I see in front of me. With these cards I tip the Panthers at huge odds, and if the teams remain as is the current price is almost impossible to ignore. Watch for announcements, and adjust your selection accordingly.

Verdict – Panthers by 8

Result - Bulldogs 24 defeated Panthers 12

Newcastle Knights vs Cronulla Sharks – Sunday afternoon – Hunter Stadium

Two of my golden rules come together in one game this weekend. Rule One - back the Knights on Sunday afternoons at home. Rule Two - don't back the Sharks on Sunday afternoons full stop. Sadly for me, one of those golden rules failed me two weeks ago when the Sharks surprised everyone and beat the Roosters on such a Sunday afternoon. As for the Knights, one win since round 4 tells me you shouldn't be backing them under any circumstances - regardless of the rules. The pincushion/petrie dish that is Paul Gallen is unlikely to play, but Cronulla aren't short of big forwards. Andrew Fifita will be keen to impress after missing out on Origin II - he's likely to return for Origin III if Gallen is out of action for a period. Is it time to break two of my golden rules? Yes it is.

Verdict – Sharks by 4

Result - Sharks 30 defeated Knights 28

Melbourne Storm vs Brisbane Broncos – Sunday afternoon – AAMI Park

Storm coach Craig Bellamy has called a press conference for this afternoon - it's probably about Billy Slater and his shoulder but anything could happen. Watch this space...or some other space where you'll hear all about it (Twitter...probably). The Broncos should have a fair amount of support in the crowd - some of the die-hards will stay on from Wednesday night and make it a festival of football. Those up in arms about Hodges not getting suspended should note this: Hodges probably won't play anyway - if he were suspended for a week it would be for this game...which he probably won't play anyway. You see what I'm saying here? Wayne Bennett is ten steps ahead of us all. I can't believe the Broncos are $1.95 for this game, and I can't believe the Storm are favourites. Ben Hunt can do his Origin prospects no harm with a match-winning performance. I'm not sure how often footballers look at the NRL ladder but if things go as I've predicted the Broncos will be standing alone at the top of NRL mountain at the conclusion of this round (and I'm never wrong). I'm tempted to have a lash, but the last time I lashed I emptied someone's purse and it didn't go so well (which is strange because I'm never wrong). And that's why you should gamble responsibly.

Verdict – Broncos by 14 (Bet of the Year!!!!!!!)

Result - Broncos 14 defeated Storm 12

St George Illawarra Dragons vs Sydney Roosters – Monday night – Allianz Stadium

We're kept waiting until Monday night to see the game of the round, but isn't this a little beauty? Third plays fifth and it's the teams with the two best defensive records in season 2015. As things stand, all Origin players have been named. The Dragons should be nice and fresh after a bye last weekend but their last performance (losing to the Bulldogs) was a bit of a head-scratcher. Conversely the Roosters impressed with a win across the ditch without their Origin players. The Chooks may be outside the top four but they do have the best points differential in the competition. A win against a team above them goes along way toward a top four finish. Note the home venue (although the Red V may get more of the crowd support regardless). Remind your eyeballs - if you only see one game this weekend make it this one.

Verdict – Roosters by 8

Result - Roosters 19 defeated Dragons 14

Wally Lewis - round fifteen selections (in bold)

Note: tips from Wally will be published on Thursday night or early Friday morning.

  • SEA EAGLES vs Tigers
  • RAIDERS vs Cowboys
  • Titans vs WARRIORS
  • BULLDOGS vs Panthers
  • KNIGHTS vs Sharks
  • Storm vs BRONCOS
  • Dragons vs ROOSTERS

Comments

Coach Potato's picture

I was referring to myself and how much crap comes out of my keyboard and where I am on the ladder compared to someone who's silence and golden tips, I'm starting to find very intimidating.

Steel Panther's picture

@a You'll be kicking yourself after posting the Warriors v Titans stats earlier in the week. It showed the Warriors have won the last four on the Gold Coast and winning five from the last eight played there then you went and tipped the Titans, the only game you ended up losing. D'oh!!

a's picture

Yes I shou
D have ex the Warriors

a's picture

Sorry for my mistake

mark ashford's picture

Congrats to ScottM well done..... a stand alone leader!
and as for you Coach keep that banter coming.
I agree with Baggy Gee your analysis is great reading and I look forward to it and everyone's comments each week.
As for your position..... as you said, there are still 83 points up for grabs.
Don't bash yourself Coach, I'm sure you're a good bloke even if you are a BLUES SUPPORTER!!

a's picture

Well I am 2 points away from the leader

christine 's picture

I also got 6 from 7 this round , a well done for being 2 points behind the ladder leader you'll catch them soon

a's picture

Yes I will

Coach Potato's picture

I bet people wouldn't know there's been an amazing 17 Origin deciders before this year.

Most paid experts share the belief that winning the first game is the most important when it comes to winning the decider, but thats a load of crap.

8 times the winner of game 1 has won the decider.
7 times the winner of game 2 has won the decider.
Twice the decider ended in a draw.

Only fair to make it 8 a piece I say.

a's picture

Not it will be nine times the team who has won game 3 after this serise

Baggy_Gee's picture

I do find that some of the exact 50/50 stats in origin to be a bit discomforting. I think a few years ago before there was 1 or 2 games seperating each and only a handful of points. Then QLD went on that streak, but it was interesting that after fo many games it could be potentially even.

Coach Potato's picture

Ask yourself how many of those series Qld would have still won with GI playing for the blues. Obviously impossible to answer, you could only imagine a lesser number though.

Sterlo playing for Qld? No disrespect but I dont think he was as much Qlds loss as GI was (is) to NSW

Coach Potato's picture

Not to be confused Baggy with the series score of Qld 20, NSW 14, 2 draws. Matches are closer Qld 55, NSW 47, 2 draws.

Consider Qld won the first 5 trophies, and 9 of the last 10. That's 14 out of 15 book end series. Says that NSW were equally as dominant in the middle period.

a's picture

Well I think QLD will win

Coach Potato's picture

Call it Lang Park JR. We want to beat them at Lang Park

a's picture

No we want QLD to win at Lang Park

Baggy_Gee's picture

Lets take the game back to QE2. The good OLD OLD OLD OLD days. the games was what I was refering to, particualry since the first few series were one off games. But games and points over the length is freaky, almost as freaky as the centeneary cricket test. Someday these similarities do make you consider match fixing.

Both the 1877, and the 1977 match at the MCG were won by Australia by 45 runs, and given that the 70's were more a bowler friendly era, quite a feat.

Coach Potato's picture

Origin would be great as a one off game just like the early days just alternating venues each year
# Everything at stake, not acceptable to lose game 1
# Trophy lifted after the game
# Grand Final feeling, as mentioned in point 1, this is it!!!
# Players and NRL teams saved from fielding understrength teams
# Fans spared from watching second rate footy for weeks on end.
# Ability for each team to have 13 home and away matches not 12
# Players spared 160 minutes where they could get injured or suspended from club games

#BringBackOneOrigin

Pages

The latest in NRL news