Finals series - week one

South Sydney Rabbitohs (2nd) vs Melbourne Storm (3rd) – Friday night – ANZ Stadium

I mentioned it last week and I'll mention it again - if there is one side the Bunnies don't want to be taking on early in the finals series it's the Melbourne Storm. Their overall record against the purple machine is woeful. Even this year, with the Bunnies flying higher than ever, they couldn't find a way to win...and they played them twice. You would think that this enormous red and green forward pack would just plough straight through the Melbourne defence - add to that the quickfire dummy-half work from Issac Luke, the general kicking games of their halves and an undeniable strike force at the back in Greg Inglis...well it all looks like a winning combination. It doesn't win because they get out-smarted by the kicking games of Cameron Smith and Cooper Cronk. Both will endeavour to find the turf with their general kicking late in tackle counts, and their kick-chase (led by Cronk himself) is the best in the business. This means those big Rabbitohs forwards will travel almost as many yards trudging backwards as they do trudging forwards - and all that extra workload takes its toll and reduces their impact. Obviously the Bunnies can win this. They'll be favourites on the night and the Storm have been below par in recent weeks, but only Manly can come close to matching the Storm for finals experience. At this level, in these games, experience counts. Assume Cronk will test the Bunnies on the edges with his kicking game. It's a strategy that tends to bear fruit, and it's much more productive than trying to test Greg Inglis.

Verdict – Storm by 7

Man of the Match - Cooper Cronk

Result - Rabbitohs 20 defeated Storm 10

Cronulla Sharks (5th) vs North Queensland Cowboys (8th) – Saturday afternoon – Allianz Stadium

You don't have to trawl too deeply into the memory banks to get a guide on how these sides lined up, as these sides lined up just two weeks ago. That was a home game for Cronulla, and they played pretty well, but the Cowboys went on to win that game fairly comfortably. Cronulla are a funny side. Their top try scorer is the biggest player in their side (Andrew Fifita) and their (equal) next best try scorer is another big bopper in Jayson Bukuya - a guy who spends much of the game on the bench. In their entire back-line, their top try-scorer is unheralded halfback Jeff Robson. Those numbers (and their points differential this season) tell me where Cronulla focus much of their game, and it's up to the Cowboys pack of forwards to withstand the onslaught. They did so two weeks ago, and I think they'll do so again. Matt Scott returns from injury, and his composure and big-game experience will take the visitors a long way. And I couldn't be more pleased with the showing of Jason Taumalolo last week. It was against ordinary opposition, but he might be starting to show his potential and he can be a very important part of the furniture in North Queensland for many seasons to come. I was also pleased with the dummy-half work of the very well-related Jayden Hodges, who, along with Kostjasyn, is helping to complete the Cowboys puzzle in the all-important dummy-half role. Sharks are favourites - I like the Cowboys.

Verdict – Cowboys by 4

Man of the Match - Jonathan Thurston

Result - Sharks 20 defeated Cowboys 18

Sydney Roosters (1st) vs Manly Sea Eagles (4th) – Saturday night – Allianz Stadium Stadium

The Sea Eagles get their toe in the door with the one week suspension to Roosters prop Jared Waerea-Hargreaves. How he gets a week off while Sam Burgess is free to play is a little bit baffling, but it won't be the last time the decisions of the judiciary leave me scratching my big beautiful head. These sides met twice earlier this season and the Roosters prevailed on both occasions, and I can't come up with enough compelling reasons to think they won't prevail again. Manly fans won't travel the hundreds and hundreds of metres required to get all the way to the Sydney Football Stadium. In a close contest, crowd support and the near faultless goal-kicking of James Maloney might prove the difference.

Verdict – Roosters by 4

Man of the Match - Anthony Minichiello

Result - Roosters 4 defeated Sea Eagles 0

Canturbury Bulldogs (6th) vs Newcastle Knights (7th) – Sunday afternoon – ANZ Stadium

These sides have met twice this season, and the Knights were victorious in both. The Novacastrians have had their ups and downs this season, but when they've been up they've been up with the best of them. The Bulldogs are favourites...short favourites, but I was far from impressed with them last week, and I just feel like we're all waiting for the Bulldogs of 2012 to emerge. I haven't seen them yet, and if we are going to see them they've certainly left their run very late. Newcastle have a backline that can score points and daytime conditions should suit. Watch for late team changes for the Bulldogs. Hasler hasn't named Frank Pritchard or Greg Eastwood and either/or both could be surprise starters. Ben Barba has been named on the bench so we'll wait and see what happens there as well. Two of the cagiest coaches in the business face off in the finals. Imagine turning up to a poker night and finding those two either side of you at the table? I think Bennett might be slightly cagier, and I'm sure he took plenty of notes when the Broncos beat the Bulldogs last weekend. Can I really select three outsiders from the four games of finals football...Yes I can.

Verdict – Knights by 1 (golden point)

Man of the Match - Tyrone Roberts

Result - Knights 22 defeated Bulldogs 6

Wally Lewis - week one finals (in bold)

Note: tips from Wally will be published on Thursday night or early Friday morning.

  • RABBITOHS vs Storm
  • Sharks vs COWBOYS
  • ROOSTERS vs Sea Eagles
  • BULLDOGS vs Knights

Comments

Bali John's picture

Morning Tinker old son, I have had a look at several differnt tipping opportunities for the 1st finals round. But from what l have read so far I see that your tips are the same as what l had picked. Only problem is if Manly get beaten I won't get to see my cowboys get even from last years Knock on by Foren in last years finals round. Also I would like to thank you for the 2013 season. Hope your back again next year.
Cheers

Lady Di's picture

Thanks again for all the tips this year Thinker.
Any idea on the aerial ping pong this weekend? Had an absolute Lady Di-saster last weekend getting 0 for 4!! Swans and Geelong this w/e perchance??
All help gratefully received!! Cheers again.

Guru Craig's picture

Storm - The Guru has made a few observations recently. Handy Sammy Boyle is a bit of a rain gauge concerning the form of the Rabbits, If Sammy is the Crusher Squirrel (trademark Big Rus Productions) then the Bunnies are doing it rough, Sam's pen-dance for indiscretions on the field seem to be intricately linked to wins and losses. Bellyache is a finals master, the bloke can coach finals football and so The Guru expects a Storm to hit ANZ Friday night. Melbourne are too good 1-12.

Cowboys - NQ are playing the football that saw the Great Man himself "The Thinker" tip the Cows for Premiership success in the pre-season write up. A great deal of this hot-run is due to Coach Henry getting the ass and sadly former Coach Murray passing away. NQ have the roster, they have the motivation and they have the JT. NQ -3.5

Roosters - Last week The Chooks held strong and delivered the win, the win that drew the score with The King and The G, alas Canberra had a different copy of the script and...Sydney were too good for the Bunnies and The G thinks they will be too much for Manly as well. I fancy this game as a coach contest. Both sides are professional, fast and highly capable, The SBW factor needs attention and J Lyon is a September specialist. Syd 1-12

Knights - Blame off-field dramas, dis-unity or dis-harmony, Ben Barba, Asada, or the Easter bunny...The Guru thinks The Doggies are goooone. Several weeks ago Des laid down the law, the boys got together for a bit of a bond, few beers, tears and you know...whatever they did, it seemed to work, Canterbury went on a run, got the season back on track and were looking very good, then the worst kept secret in league, BB, followed the exit (jumping ship?) of their CEO, rumors of all sorts..mostly players wanting out began to surface...many untrue, however the vibe coming out of Belmore isn't
all too positive.

Johnny Ray's picture

Yeah Hey Thinker !

Thanks again for doing this and thanks dude for putting the points in ! With that, here are my tips for this round :

Storm - This could seriously be blowout as Rabbits just can't seem to be able to play pressure footy ( just look at how they played last week ) ! When it all comes down to it, I just don't see Rabbits being up to it. Storm by 12.

Sharks - This will be close but I still think Sharks will win this cause I still see game getting away from Cowboys in second half. That and with what I'm hearing on news about Sharks, this could be Paul Gallen last game and don't see Paul Gallen losing his last game. Sharks by 8.

Sea Eagles - The Roosters played their first final game last week against Rabbits and I can't seem putting in the same intensity again for second week in row, not when they have lost one of their important players. Sea Eagles should just get over Roosters in this one but still way I see it game could either way. Sea Eagles by 4.

Knights - Bulldogs just aren't playing like the same team as they did last year and alot of that is because Ben Barba just isn't same player anymore as he has been in negative head space all year. Psychologically he's already beaten and because of that so are Bulldogs. Knights to beat Bulldogs in this game. Knights by 6.

Go Auckland Vulcans ! Seriously now that Warriors aren't in it, can't we put all out players in our NSW feeder team ? I want to see us win something ! ;-D

Steel Panther's picture

Bali John...I understand that if the Cowboys win and Manly lose this weekend that they will play each other next week. Now won't that be an interesting match up given what happened last season!

flash's picture

are all the games qualifiers? or are 5-8 eliminations? STORM-SHARKS-ROOSTERS-DOGGIES

a's picture

Here are my tips

Rabbitohs 26-22 tries Walker 2 Sutton Luke Ingles Renyolds 3/5 Storm tries Smith Proctor O'Neill Bromwich Smith 3/4
Man of the match Sutton

Cowboys 24-22 tries Tate Ulugia Cooper Lui Thruston 4/5 Sharks tries Gallen 2 Feki Tupou Carney 3/4
Man of the match Lui

Roosters 28-22 tries Maloney Kenny-Dowall 2 Tuivasa-Sheck Tupou Maloney 4/5 Many tries Matai 2 Symonds Taufua Lyon 4/5
Man of the match Kenny-Dowall

Bulldogs 28-20 tries Perrett Inu Ennis Lafai Hodkinson 6/6 Knights tries Uate McManus Hilder Leliua 4/5
Man of the match Hodinson

Bali John's picture

Panther, Yes you are completly right l never looked at the draw. This would be one game l would love to see . I still go for the Cowboys too cause Matts back.
Good luck all.
PS. I would love to see one of the teams next year bring one of their home games up here. After all we are having Miss world here now. APEC next month as well as the Bali 10's Rugby The world surfing titles several months back. Many of the players visit here on the off season as well, so would love to see a Real League game played up here.
Might just have to tweet JT.

cupcake's picture

Knocked the Boss off his perch this year and TOOK the office tipping completion! Achieved legendary status and run off with the cash. Sweet victory to the cupcake! Many thanks to you all for a fantastic season of tipping and amusing commentry, loved every minute of it. Will return next year... go chooks.

Steel Panther's picture

Storm, Sharks, Roosters, Dogs and Warriors Under 20s!!

mark ashford's picture

Well done cupcake love to hear one of the thinker,s family has won their comp.
I like Storm, Cowboys, Manly and the Knights.

Johnny Boney's picture

My tips

Rabbitohs-20 Storm-12
Tries in time:
7th minute rabbitohs 4- storm- 0
9th minute rabbitohs-6 storm-0
11th minute rabbitohs 10 storm-0
12th minute rabbitohs 12 storm-0
26th minute rabbitohs 12 storm 4
27th minute rabbitohs 12 storm 6
33rd minute rabbitohs 12 storm 10
35th minute rabbitohs 12 storm-12
38th minute rabbitohs 14 storm 12

Half-Time Rabbitohs-14 Storm-12

76th minute Rabbitohs 18 Storm 12
78th minute Rabbitohs 20 Storm 12

Full time Rabbitohs 20 storm 12

Sharks 12 Cowboys 26

Half-Time Sharks 0 Cowboys 0

54th minute Sharks 4 Cowboys 0
55th minute Sharks 6 Cowboys 0
58th minute Sharks 10 Cowboys 0
60th minute Sharks 12 Cowboys 0
64th minute Sharks 12 Cowboys 4
65th minute Sharks 12 Cowboys 6
69th minute Sharks 12 Cowboys 10
70th minute Sharks 12 Cowboys 12
73rd minute Sharks 12 Cowboys 16
75th minute Sharks 12 Cowboys 18
77th minute Sharks 12 Cowboys 22
79th minute Sharks 12 Cowboys 24
80th minute Sharks 12 Cowboys 26

Full-Time Sharks 12 Cowboys 26

Roosters 38 Sea Eagles 14

1st minute Roosters 4 Sea Eagles 0
2nd minute Roosters 6 Sea Eagles 0
9th minute Roosters 10 Sea Eagles 0
10th minute Roosters 12 Sea Eagles 0
12th minute Roosters 16 Sea Eagles 0
14th minute Roosters 18 Sea Eagles 0
20th minute Roosters 18 Sea Eagles 4
22nd minute Roosters 18 Sea Eagles 6
23rd minute Roosters 18 Sea Eagles 10
24th minute Roosters 18 Sea Eagles 12
40th minute Roosters 18 Sea Eagles 14

Half-Time Roosters 18 Sea Eagles 14

52nd minute Roosters 22 Sea Eagles 14
53rd minute Roosters 24 Sea Eagles 14
57th minute Roosters 28 Sea Eagles 14
59th minute Roosters 30 Sea Eagles 14
68th minute Roosters 34 Sea Eagles 14
74th minute Roosters 38 Sea Eagles 14

Full-Time Roosters 38 Sea Eagles 14

Bulldogs 12 Knights 40

25th minute Bulldogs 0 Knights 4
26th minute Bulldogs 0 Knights 6
34th minute Bulldogs 0 Knights 10
36th minute Bulldogs 0 Knights 12

Half-Time Bulldogs 0 Knights 12

62nd minute Bulldogs 0 Knights 16
63rd minute Bulldogs 0 Knights 18
64th minute Bulldogs 0 Knights 22
66th minute Bulldogs 0 Knights 24
67th minute Bulldogs 0 Knights 28
68th minute Bulldogs 0 Knights 30
69th minute Bulldogs 0 Knights 34
71st minute Bulldogs 0 Knights 36
77th minute Bulldogs 0 Knights 40
78th minute Bulldogs 4 Knights 40
79th minute Bulldogs 6 Knights 40
80th minute Bulldogs 10 Knights 40
80th minute Bulldogs 12 Knights 40

Full-Time Bulldogs 12 Knights 40

cupcake's picture

thankyou, cupcake curtseys :-)

rangerchris's picture

Late starter but thanks all the same for the tips. Look forward to the rest of the finals and then next year

Chris
Lonely Broncos Supporter

The latest in NRL news