2019 NRL Grand Final

Sydney Roosters vs Canberra Raiders – Sunday night – ANZ Stadium

Sydney Roosters

  1. James Tedesco
  2. Daniel Tupou
  3. Latrell Mitchell
  4. Joseph Manu
  5. Brett Morris
  6. Luke Keary
  7. Cooper Cronk
  8. Jared Waerea-Hargreaves
  9. Sam Verrills
  10. Isaac Liu
  11. Boyd Cordner (c)
  12. Mitch Aubusson
  13. Victor Radley
  14. Angus Crichton
  15. Zane Tetevano
  16. Nat Butcher
  17. Siosiua Taukeiaho

Canberra Raiders

  1. Charnze Nicoll-Klokstad
  2. Nick Cotric
  3. Jarrod Croker (c)
  4. Joseph Leilua
  5. Jordan Rapana
  6. Jack Wighton
  7. Aidan Sezer
  8. Josh Papalii
  9. Josh Hodgson
  10. Iosia Soliola
  11. John Bateman
  12. Elliott Whitehead
  13. Joseph Tapine
  14. Bailey Simonnsen
  15. Emre Guler
  16. Corey Horsburgh
  17. Dunamis Lui

* note that team line-ups are subject to change and will be updated as soon as possible

The finals campaigns of the Roosters and the Raiders have much in common. Both were victorious in week one, put their boots up in week two, then won again in week three to be the teams left standing in the most important game of the year. Impressively the similarities don't end there, because by the luck of the draw our two finalists played and won against the same two teams to progress. The Rabbits lost to the Roosters in week one and the Raiders in week three, while the Storm lost to the Raiders in week one and the Roosters in week three.

This is noteworthy for a few reasons:

  • No-one can accuse one team of having an easier path into the grand final (granted the Raiders did have to win away from home in week one).
  • While they both got a week off, the teams they did play and beat are the other two top four teams for the season.
  • For those of us in the business of trying to pick a winner, being able to compare two teams that have done similar things is handy reference material.

The reference material is a good read. Jumping off the page are the defensive performances by both teams this finals campaign. The Raiders conceded just 10 points in both games which is very good going against very good opponents. While impressive, the Chooks conceded just 6 points in both games. The old masters of the game will tell you defence wins premierships – it's certainly the case this year.

In attack the Roosters have scored more points with the ball this finals series (44 vs the Raiders 28). This isn't much of a surprise, as the Roosters have scored 100+ more points than the Raiders during the regular season, and they have a backline that could test the Harlem Globetrotters. The Raiders have plenty of firepower too, just a few less rockets than their opponent here.

These sides have already played twice this season, so it would be pretty silly of me to ignore that. In round 9 they met in Brisbane where the Roosters won 30-24, and in round 21 they met in Canberra where the Roosters won 22-18. Both games were competitive and high quality, but the Roosters won them both, and they won them both away from Sydney. In round 21 the team lists were pretty similar to our Grand Final teams. The Chooks scored 4 tries to 3, and the while the Raiders had their chances and closed the game out strongly, they couldn't get the win. No team in the NRL defend their line like the Chooks.

The other notable notable is the return of the big man on campus...Jared Waerea-Hargreaves. In a sport with no shortage of big men, his inclusion is impossible to ignore. I don't think he improves the Chooks defence a lot (if anything, his occasional discrepancies can give opponents a piggy back from time to time), but he does seem to help get the Roosters attack moving in the right direction. It's the speed of his carries and the ground he makes that gives this fabulous Roosters backline the head-start it needs to shine.

It's been an extraordinarly long time since the Raiders won a premiership. It's been an even longer time since we had back-to-back premiers. To the neutral observer the Raiders are the feel-good story of the season, but both stories are good in their way. Cronk can finish his career with another premiership. He can't be more herculean than last season (at least you hope he doesn't have to be), but he's a good egg. Sometimes nice guys finish first.

Verdict – Roosters by 6

First try scorer – Joseph Manu

Clive Churchill Medalist – Jack Wighton



Result – Roosters 14 defeated Raiders 8

First try scorer – Sam Verrills

Clive Churchill Medalist – Jack Wighton

Wally Lewis - grand final selection (in bold)

Note: tips from Wally will be published on Wednesday night or early Thursday morning.

  • ROOSTERS vs Raiders

Comments

christine's picture

Thinker I just read in tweets jeff fenech is in hospital in Thailand with a collapsed lung & a serious bout of pneumonia he is in icu ...

NuL1F3's picture

Hi to all you wonderful tipsters! Last game for the year and as much as I would love to tip Raiders, I have to go Roosters to take home the silverware. If it were a Raiders home game..? I might be more tempted to go the other way but as it's not, I will be joining the masses with my tip. I hope everyone enjoys this final game and has a great off season!!

BigPeteBx's picture

Hello Christine and all other regulars here.
I read this morning that former St George great Eddie Lumsden from Kurri Kurri, passed away on eve of grand final, this morning.

RIP Eddie and condolences to all associated and those here who are Dragons followers.

Johnny A - got ya email mate and enjoy your visit to mum and tonight's game.

Regards all - Big Pete Bx

Christine 's picture

Big Pete I didn't know yes R. I. P. Eddie lumsden you are in your thoughts & won't be forgotten

christine's picture

I have myself all sorted out for the grand final tonight I am cooking a baked dinner ( lamb ) & for afterwards I have these individual cakes \ tarts from a cake shop where I live in fact they might get consumed before the lamb seeing I didn't have lunch I will spoil myself , have fun watching tonights game everyone ...

NuL1F3's picture

Just about to kick off! I'm expecting a truly great game 😁

Baggy_Gee's picture

So depressed I was left out anon. Do I fail to rate a mention.

Steel Panther's picture

Where you been Baggy? Haven't heard from you since your Eels bowed out.

NuL1F3's picture

Raiders looking tough! Are the Roosters running out of steam already? Raiders may end up clapping their way to victory after all. The final 40 just around the corner!

NuL1F3's picture

Congrats to the Roosters fans (surely there are more here than Newbie?) for a back to back win. Roosters fought hard against a very tough Raiders side tonight.

Baggy_Gee's picture

Been a fraction rough on the home front. School holidays, uni assignments, the usual. I'm here, just not as vocal.

a's picture

Raiders lost because of the refs

Christine 's picture

You know if I Was an animal with everything that's wrong with me they would just put me down I have so much fluid retention at the moment my legs hurt my feet hurt my father doesn't even bother to watch origin with me anymore now he doesn't even watch the grand final with me ...

Christine 's picture

Now we are in for a long off season enjoy your break everyone I will still be posting in the off season...

Christine 's picture

Anonymous both you & spartan warrior are on here posting comments to me calling me lady Christine on the same day only spartan does that don't copy people trying to portray yourself as them I am not partaking in any of it I told him you were doing so...

BigPeteBx's picture

Evenin NuLife - yes mate Thinker is one, I am certain.
Plus Pabdul who once existed here.

I took Chooks in tipping at work and here, so I guess The Feathers join ranks tonight.

Cheers - Big Pete

BigPeteBx's picture

Evenin 'a' - I'm sure there was a Sutton there - again.

Cheers, have a great off-season and keep well
Big Pete

NuL1F3's picture

Good evening bigpete 🙂

BigPeteBx's picture

Hey Baggy - hang in there champ.
What you doing at Uni?

Cheers and "sneek a peek" in here, during off-season.
Big Pete

BigPeteBx's picture

Good evenin to you again NuLife.
Close game - I took Chooks with a margin of 7, as I was certain one of them would be giving a field goal, an attempt.
Cheers - Big Pete

BigPeteBx's picture

Hello Christine - I guess some of the regulars will check in now and then. I'll be about, but over on the "Off-Season" Page.

How did that baked lamb go, it's so costly to buy these days?
I saw lamb cutlets at our butchers last week at $39.99 a kilo. At that price, we'd need to eat the bone, as well.
Cheers, keep well and take it steady - Big Pete

Baggy_Gee's picture

Upskilling Pete, turning experience into a piece of paper to get a job. It's just my week to have to struggles, next week it'll all turn around and be golden. As to the paper, business and a bit of law.

Christine 's picture

Big Pete I don't pay that price & from now on k will naff buy it bone in it is a hour $20 00 a kilo or more cheaper that way but it was enough just for one person knowing my father He will come home tomorrow while i am out eat what is left He does that when I am not here & leaves me the mess to clean up like I am his servant I really can'f be bothered with him ,I hope to speak to you again on the off season big Pete "a" & myself sill be Doing # maybe mark, ashford maybe newbie might stick around who knows I no spartan will...

The Thinker's picture

Greetings football fans

Another season done and dusted. I have updated the final standings in the 2019 tipping comp. Congrats to our top three prizewinners – Footy Chick, BigPeteBx and JackStarky. I will be in touch with the three of you to organise prizes and, most importantly, your names are forever etched on the tipping competition honour board. Long after your prizemoney has been spent on milk shakes and meat pies, your place on the honour board will remain.

Outstanding tipping from all three of you this year, a tight contest to the very end.

Thanks again to all the participants and contributors...and those of you that just like to have a peek inside but do so quietly. I appreciate you taking the time to be here.

1.16 million pairs of eyeballs over the course of the 2019 season...pretty incredible really for a dodgy little website that publishes one page a round.

Feel free to poke around during the off season, and I'll be back (like Tina Turner) in 2020 to do it all again.

 

BigPeteBx's picture

Thinker &TLH -
the real congrats go to you guys, who have made the Thinker NRL Tipping pages so successful, for us all to enjoy and be part of.
Its great being here and for me to be the "bridesmaid" on two of those occasions and to be gathered among great people, is also an honour.

Well done again Footy Chick and Jack Starky!
We had several putting the pressure on us, which made for careful examination on our weekly tipping.

Many thanks to all tipsters and contributors, you/we certainly kept the rounds alive and the site going strong, with postings of all nature and topics.

Cheers, take care and keep well - Big Pete Bx

BigPeteBx's picture

Best wishes with it all BG and good luck.
In some of my away from work duties, I get to rub shoulders with a few in that sector. Some are business managers, practice managers or office managers. Go for it mate and I hope you get into the field that you profess or desire.

Keep the little ladies (daughters) and your wife interested here, as we have a lovely combination of people. May our clubs go the extra next year and best of all, may the players stay out of the media, for all the wrong reasons.

Cheers and keep well - Big Pete

BigPeteBx's picture

It doubled up BG - spooler must be running slow, but posting hadn't disappeared from Comment Box.
So that's DOUBLE THE LUCK and wishes for you.

Cheers - Big Pete

Steel Panther's picture

Congrats to Footy Chick (the most mentioned name on the Honours Board) and to Big Pete (hopefully not forever the bridesmaid) and newcomer Jack Starky. Grand tipping from all three off you!!

Thanks to The Thinker and TLH for another fun season. No doubt it takes a bit of time and effort to provide us with this awesome site. Great to converse with so many people who love the great game as much as I do and contribute to this site in their own unique way.

To my new "friend for life" Mark Ashford...I'll see you in a couple of weeks where I hope to meet another Thinker poster the lovely Manyana.

Best wishes to all
SP

Mary S's picture

Mr Thinker,
You forgot to add your own result for the Grand Final!

For picking the 6 point differential, you should surely get additional points!!!!
Cheers,
Mary

NuL1F3's picture

Congratulations to our three top tipsters :D Bring on 2020!!

@BigPete I too chose a margin of 7! No field goal in a grand final? Though I guess the win was controversial enough?

I look forward to catching up with everyone next season, and seeing what kind of footy we end up getting to watch. Thanks to all that make this site such an interesting read week in week out. GO COWBOYS!

BigPeteBx's picture

NuLife - mate 7 was close in tippers terms, because someone would have had a pot shot if they'd have realised it was heading for a draw.
A draw yes - when you see Joey Leilua storming down the sideline in full flight.

BigPeteBx's picture

So in continuation NuLife - Hey Bro there are field goals in grand finals.
Give JT a call and ask him.

Cheers and keep well
Big Pete in Bx

NuL1F3's picture

Hi BigPeteBx, yeah mate don't I know it!! 2015 was a very good year :D

BigPeteBx's picture

Great to hear back from you NuLife - 2015 was a good year and it wasn't car tyres either.
She's Action Jackson over this way (more than car tyres) these next couple of days.
Plenty of peoples around. Wife met an elderly couple who have come/driven all the way from West Aust. The hubby said "if his wife didn't come with him, he'd have ridden his bike over".
That's keen mate and keener than mustard!

Cheers and keep well - Big Pete in Bx Country (vroom,vroom).

NuL1F3's picture

Hahaha! Keener than mustard indeed! :P

newbie from perth's picture

ONCE UPON A TIME

Once upon a time, a long, long time ago there were two tribes that decided to go into battle to determine once and for all, who should receive the blessings of the gods for their heroic deeds of the year just passed.

The gods decided these 34 warriors should meet on the battlefield known as the ANZ Stadium at a pre-appointed hour and engage each other in gladiatorial contest to see who would gain the gods’ favour. To the victor go the spoils. This is the tale of that epic battle. Read on if you dare…

It was Sunday the 6th October 2019 and the Sydney Roosters lived the fairytale and became the first team to win back-to-back premierships in 26 years in an engrossing grand final in front of nearly 83,000 fans at ANZ Stadium. Showing their typical grit and defensive effort, the Roosters withstood an enormous amount of pressure from a tenacious Raiders side and somehow survived. They basically defended their way to the ultimate 14-6 triumph. It might’ve been more had Latrell Mitchell not missed those 2 penalties in the 40th and 69th minutes.

The Roosters started (very) well and raced to a 6-nil lead after only 6 minutes. Then Aubusson does his knee in the 14th minute which throws the Roosters’ interchange plans into semi-disarray. Shortly after Aubusson goes off, Victor Radley goes off for HIA. The Raiders start to get back into the game, momentum shifts and it’s all Raiders for the rest of the first half. That dominance continues on for 30 minutes into the second half as well.

OK, so Cooper Cronk gets binned in the 50th minute. That was a harsh call. He tackles one millisecond before Papalii receives the pass but seriously, you’re gonna call that as a professional foul? I suppose in the context of the rules it was correct but really, what’s a little fella to do against a big fella in that situation? Meh! It could possibly be very easy to counter that “six-again” argument (more on that below) with that borderline ludicrous sin binning. Down to 12 blokes and the Raiders still couldn’t get through the Roosters’ resolute defence. I know what that tells me. What does it tell you?

Speaking of that 72nd minute “six-again” drama … here’s my 2c for what it’s worth.

As it turned out, Cummins got the call from Gerard Sutton (and the linesman) letting him know the ball had actually bounced off a Raiders’ player and he immediately changed the call and apparently yelled out “last tackle” 4 or 5 times. Yeah, I understand Wighton saw Cummins waving his arm for six again but that’s no excuse for him (and players around him) ignoring the ref’s calls. A better option would’ve been to have a little chip kick instead maybe. Whatever.

On the live broadcast, Ray “Rabs” Warren called it as off a Canberra player straightaway. Post-match, Peter Sterling reckons it didn’t cost them the game. I’ve seen it countless times and it did indeed come off the Canberra player. I suppose it’s not the deflection off the Raiders’ player that’s got everyone hot under the collar but moreso the gaffe from Cummins in getting it wrong and waving his arm for six again.

Yeah, it was heartbreaking for the Raiders and their fans, especially considering the winning try from the Roosters came shortly after, but that’s life. As I said last week, someone has to win and someone has to lose. That’s just how it is.

As some pundits have mentioned, this grand final will be remembered for all the wrong reasons. And that’s a real shame I reckon. Seriously, if anyone thinks for one moment the Raiders were “robbed” of a grand final win because of that “six-again” debacle, they’re deluding themselves. And I’m not being one-eyed here either. You just need to take an honest overview of the game you watched. No doubt this will be hotly debated for many years to come but I will feel very comfortable in myself believing the Roosters won the grand final fair and square.

I reckon a lot of people will be wondering how the Raiders managed to lose the grand final actually. For the majority of the match they did indeed look like the better team. For obvious reasons (to me at least) they couldn’t find the “knockout punch”. Sort of reminds me of Apollo Creed trying to knock out Rocky in their 2nd fight 💪.

Look, if the Raiders were good enough they would’ve got up but they didn’t so they weren’t. It’s as simple as that I’m afraid. As much as I feel for them with that “6-again” debacle, the truth of the matter is that it wasn’t the thing that lost them the game. Hopefully the Raiders will look back on this over the break and come to realise they let themselves down just a bit and that their inability to make the most of their opportunities (and possession) more than likely was the reason they lost and not because of that one isolated “6-again” drama.

Maybe losing this grand final will spur them on next year and instil some desire to prove to the rugby league world that they are indeed good enough. Jack Wighton was a deserved winner of the Clive Churchill medal. It was an absolutely awesome effort from him. To his credit, Jack was reported as saying … "But we're definitely not going to blame a ref for our loss, we had more than enough opportunities."

The best part of the game for me (obviously) was when Tedesco scored. Keary passes to Mitchell. Beautiful flick pass from Mitchell to Tupou. Daniel then passes to Tedesco. Tedesco runs in and scores. When the roar from the (greatly outnumbered) Sydney fans went up another level when Tedesco got the ball and they realised he was gonna score, it got me so “pumped” it’s almost impossible to describe. Joy? Relief? Happiness? I suppose you could say all three of those actually. I’m sure all my neighbours heard me at that point yelling out a primal scream of “you-rude word starting with an F-beauty”. Man I was pumped! 💪 I still get goosebumps every time I watch that try. Yeah sad I know, but I’ve watched it maybe 10 times so far 😃.

At the end of the day, it was the Roosters’ defence that proved the difference (just like it did against the Storm the previous week) and again, it was when they were up against it in the second half. Their defence was just too strong for the Raiders. They simply stood up and copped everything the Raiders threw at them and survived. One piece of brilliance (luck) in the 72nd minute and bam! 💥

Stats-wise, it was close in a lot of areas but there were quite a few that surprised me and one in particular. Roosters (obviously) had less possession (46%-54%), less tackle breaks (30-39), less offloads (1-19), less effective tackles (82.3%-91.8%), more missed tackles (39-30) and the one that surprised me … the number of ineffective tackles. The Roosters had 38 and the Raiders had 1. Yeah, the Raiders had just one (1) ineffective tackle. At first I thought that was a typo but I checked it on the NRL website and it’s correct. Sheesh!

Anyways, that’s my take on the “big dance” of 2019. I know (for a fact) there will be people who disagree with what I’ve just served up and that’s fine with me. We all have our own opinions and I’m cool with that. All I know is I’ve been as unbiased and honest as I can be and that my BBB have gone back-to-back and I’m very happy indeed. Begurk! 🐔 Begurk! 🐔

OK kids, stay well, keep safe and enjoy life 😍 Cheers…

mark ashford's picture

Newbie
I've just read your analysis of the game and feel there is no need for me to watch a replay as I trust your honesty.
Only 2 things I might question you on (remember I haven't seen it in full only highlights) First is Cronk took Papalli out more than a second before he took the ball. At that time Josh had a pretty clear run to the line and should have scored, he's such a big unit. Cronk is a very clever player and knew what he was doing. Second is the refs debacle which led to Teddies try. Had the Raiders known it was the last they would have kicked down field to who knows what result.
Your stats also interest me, indicating Raiders were the best on field.
I can't help but come back to how much influence Nick Politis has at the NRL, maybe the refs f-up explains it all.
Anyway my friend enjoy your victory. The Roosters won and it's now history. Interestingly enough Ricky Stewart, after the game, didn't blame the refs (unusual for him) but accepted the result. So maybe my comments are off the mark a bit.

Pages

The latest in NRL news