Round twenty three selections

South Sydney Rabbitohs vs Canterbury Bulldogs – Thursday night – ANZ Stadium

It's never been more important for your team to have a good fullback, and I mean a bloody good fullback. Every player wearing the number one jersey in the NRL this weekend has been racking up tries this season...but one. Will Hopoate, bless him, is in grave danger of facing the nudie run this season. To go along with his 0 tries he has made just one line break this year. It's not a good look, particularly when you consider that the Rabbitohs haven't had a great season either, but their fullback on Thursday night has 17 tries and 13 line breaks this season. Hopoate clearly isn't the only reason the Bulldogs are struggling this year, but he's on the list of reasons. That Bulldogs forward pack is first class, and if your backs can't create tries on the back of that pack something is clearly wrong. This is the fourth successive Thursday night game for the Bulldogs and they have been terrible and terribly boring every single time. Channel Nine must be shaking their heads in dismay.

Verdict – Rabbitohs by 8

Result – Rabbitohs by 14

Parramatta Eels vs Newcastle Knights – Friday night – ANZ Stadium

It's not often a team running last would have smiles on their faces, but the Knights dressing shed would be a slightly happier place at the minute. Back-to-back wins for the first time since forever and a bunch of young locals getting better each and every week. There's half a dozen teams in the NRL that could learn a thing or two from the team running last. While they can't win on Friday night, they will give a good account of themselves and that makes this game a heck of a lot more watchable than the Thursday night grind. The Eels are on a roll and have a sweet run into the finals. Top four looks likely now but I think they should try to aim one spot higher. Top four means your first final will probably be against the Storm in Melbourne. I'm sure they would rather play a Sydney team in Sydney.

Verdict – Eels by 14

Result – Eels by 19

Brisbane Broncos vs Cronulla Sharks – Friday night – Suncorp Stadium

Both sides will have plenty to play for in this – assuming the Eels beat the Knights, the team that loses this game slips out of the top four. Right now the Sharks are paying $3.00 to win this game and here are three reasons why they can pull off an upset:

  1. They've played nine games away from home this season and they've won eight of them (their only away loss was that underwater game on the Gold Coast). Those away victories include wins over three genuine contenders this season – Storm, Roosters and Eels.
  2. The Sharks were pretty ordinary last start and they know it. They have a habit of bouncing back from a poor performance.
  3. Paul Gallen is king of the nub-nubs but he's playing his 300th game on Friday night – I expect his team will lift.

The Broncos were great to watch against the Titans, but you have to question the willingness of their opponent in that game. The Sharks will be willing, and I think they are willing and able to pull off an upset. Note the return of Maloney – just on goal-kicking alone he helps the Sharks in what I assume will be a tight contest.

Verdict – Sharks by 2

Result – Sharks by 22

St George Illawarra Dragons vs Gold Coast Titans – Saturday afternoon – UOW Jubilee Oval

Dragons coach Mary McGregor hasn't had much of a fortnight – a loss to the Knights, a $10000 fine, an extraordinary loss to the Rabbitohs and his team have fallen out of the top eight. I've a feeling they'll win here, but mainly because I feel like the Titans have given up. The Titans did beat the Dragons in round 17, but the Titans were well and truly trying then. I could easily have this wrong, but I'm with the Red V in front of their faithful army.

Verdict – Dragons by 8

Result – Dragons by 26

Melbourne Storm vs Sydney Roosters – Saturday night – AAMI Park

First plays second in the game of the round, but I do feel like there's quite the gap between first and second this season. Two rounds back I raised my doubts about the Roosters credentials and the Chooks got up and won after looking wobbly early on (Thinker shakes fist). Then I decided I must have been wrong about them, tipped them last weekend and they were pretty darn ordinary (Thinker shakes fist again). Perhaps I was right to doubt, but I do note that they are a vastly improved seventeen with Cordnor and Friend back on the paddock. That's not enough for this doubting Thomas though – Cameron 'The Accountant' Smith will note the ladder positions going into this game, he'll crunch the numbers and he'll work out that winning this game all but seals the minor premiership for the purple machine. Smith likes trophies.

Verdict – Storm by 7

Result – Storm by 3

Penrith Panthers vs North Queensland Cowboys – Saturday night – Pepper Stadium

Some games are crunchier than others, and this is a real crunch game for the Cowboys. A loss here and I have them slipping to eighth on the ladder, and the teams in 9th and 10th will be just two points behind. The Cowboys haven't had to spend too much time in Sydney this season (for the sake of an argument I'm calling Penrith as Sydney...close enough surely). This will be just their fourth game in the harbour city and their three previous visits have resulted in two losses (to the Sharks and Roosters) and one win (over the Bulldogs). This is the toughest opponent the Panthers have faced in a while but they have won five in a row. They lost to the Cowboys by just two points in Townsville, and I'll bank on home ground advantage getting them over the line on this occasion.

Verdict – Panthers by 4

Result – Panthers by 8

New Zealand Warriors vs Canberra Raiders – Sunday afternoon – Mt Smart Stadium

Tallking about the Warriors just makes me cranky so I won't be saying much, but I will say this – Ryan Hoffman is back this week and maybe, just maybe, he can talk his troops into putting in half an effort on Sunday. That's the only glimmer of light I can see for the home side here. Bah!.

Verdict – Raiders by 14

Result – Raiders by 20

Wests Tigers vs Manly Sea Eagles – Sunday afternoon – Leichhardt Oval

Manly are in seventh place on the ladder and the teams in 6th and 8th are playing each other on Saturday night. If the Cowboys lose the Sea Eagles can move into 6th place with a win. If the Panthers lose the Sea Eagles can put a four point gap on their nearest rival. Either way a win shores up their finals prospects. Their performance against the Roosters indicated that they've found their mojo. Back the total points overs if you're into that sort of thing – this game looks like one of those 44-26 kinda scorelines (weather permitting).

Verdict – Sea Eagles by 16

Result – Tigers by 4

Wally Lewis - round twenty three selections (in bold)

Note: tips from Wally will be published on Wednesday night or early Thursday morning.

  • RABBITOHS vs Bulldogs
  • EELS vs Knights
  • BRONCOS vs Sharks
  • DRAGONS vs Titans
  • STORM vs Roosters
  • PANTHERS vs Cowboys
  • Warriors vs RAIDERS
  • Tigers vs SEA EAGLES

Comments

BigPeteBx's picture

Howdy Pabdul - I've just returned from a Sports Council Mtg I attend every month. Gee mate, hope your dad is ok. 6 runs to go - hope he gets it. You didn't make him sit on the roof again. You guys like Adelaide. I do also, as I had some friends over there until they moved to Pt Augusta and Strathy. Thanks for added confidence with eye op.
Not into blurred vision, its enough when we can't see for the fog here.
Cheers SBAB.

BigPeteBx's picture

Thanks Mark A - sounds amazing what they can do these days.
The thing I think about, is the hospitals these days.....with Golden Staph.
Not good and I know one fellow that is on antibiotics for the rest of his life, over it.
One of my eyes is very short sighted, so maybe the lens replacement might give me some sight I never had.
Keep well mate.

a's picture

BigPete in the NBA I follow the Charlotte Hornets and in the the NFL well I support the Dallas Cowboys I surprised you didn't already figure this one out

a's picture

Henry about to get sacked that's rubbish Hayne only plays when he wants he is so selfish and when he doesn't have a good game he comes of injured or has a temtrim so I think Hayne should be sacked not Henry

BigPeteBx's picture

Thanks for that B/Gee, much appreciate that.
I'm still Manly.......that many dislike in the club. But all clubs do what they do mate. I bear no grudges. I take winning like losing, but after yesterday, I wondered where they dropped their bundle and I think all the positiveness was left back in the dressing shed.
Count on me Baggy, if ever I am in your district, I'll let you know beforehand and we might catch up for a "ginger beer" or three.

@Pabdul - I'll be in your area in December, as I have tickets to Paul McCartney Concert at Qudos and I think this time we might be staying in P/matta. So it would be nice for you to walk over and meet and greet, even if to say hello and then mums the word,

Cheers - Big Pete

BigPeteBx's picture

Thanks Miss Chris and B/Gee and my SBAB Pabdul.
Its nice to know how we all feel, after the close interaction of footy.
Its a game, but we all have a life. I like to think of friendliness and not war/argies.
You guys keep well and enjoy the rest of the week.
Round 24 approaching - where on earth has this season and year gone.
Cheers - Big Pete

BigPeteBx's picture

Love ya Pabdul - feathers and all.
Although it would be a little cool with you after the past two weeks mate. Hows those toots toots going. Thomas would be proud of you.

BigPeteBx's picture

Gee Christine, sounds like that plane is in all directions.
The yanky NFL ego that is stuck on him.

BigPeteBx's picture

Dont have to be sorry Christine.
What you first wrote equates to $1.2mill, it was only that you left a comma out and we in the numbers game, can see what you meant.
Cheers - Pete

BigPeteBx's picture

I say Christine - a few of those o's and a few $$$$, wouldn't go astray.
Might even make for a great Thinker members/followers re-union.
Cheers - go a rest those eyes. I'm about to call it Goodnight Irene.
Big Pete

BigPeteBx's picture

Thanks 'a".
Nice to know that I've kept the peace for my other bro's of Brooky fame.

Look, some have a dig and if the return is a boiling point, then it is there where the aggression starts kicking in. As it did before.
I try to sway away from it and those type scenarios.
Cheers Cobber
Pete

BigPeteBx's picture

'a' - I had a feeling you might have been a Dallas Ewing.
I'm for sure that was the team I elected to support in NFL, then LA Dodgers or NY Yankees in baseball - not sure there JR.
Cheers and its Goodnight from He.

BigPeteBx's picture

I sense a degree of disruption down on the G/Coast.
Skuse me.....but why the dumbarses paid all that cabbage for him is beyond my belief. Wherever he goes he will be a one man band.
We've got our own issues at Manly and most of it stems from Nth Sydney Teddy Bear days & Nthn Eagles. Loved N/Sydney area.
Been to their club over at Cammeray. Nice leafy suburb there. Took a look through the gates at Nth Sydney Oval and saw The Molly Dye Stand. Will one day take a walk through.
Clock is ticking...........snoozies calling.
Cheers and loved the discussions.........you all keep well.
Big Pete

christine's picture

The problem with hayne big pete is he doesn't want to train & the coach is the one to get axed for not being able to pull him in line which is all an excuse it wasn't neil henry that wanted hayne the board did & do you really think the board are going to admit they made a mistake i don't think so neil henry is being made the escape goat , the ? Is who is going to be the coach now & how long is it going to take for hayne to get rid of them , alright good people speak to you tomorrow i'm going to bed my eyes are watering & blurry ...

tigerholic's picture

Hi Christine

In answering "A's" question, I don't believe Benji would be coming home if Jason Taylor was still the coach.

Welcome back Benji:)

Craig's picture

I think the results for week 23 do not appear to be correct...caused me all types of grief when I challenged my results this week ha ha ha

https://the-thinker.org/nrl-tips/2017/round-twenty-three-selections
Your Prediction Your Result Actual Result
==================================
Eels by 14 Eels by 19 Knights by 19
Sharks by 2 Sharks by 22 Broncos by 22

regards
Craig

PS
Love your site

Pages

The latest in NRL news