Round twenty four selections

Wests Tigers vs Manly Sea Eagles – Thursday night – Campbelltown Stadium

Despite what the lads from Manly are saying, recent results would indicate that the Sea Eagles have put their pencils down this season. Their only victory in recent weeks was over the Bulldogs, in a game that was billed as a battle to assure avoidance of the wooden spoon. Manly have found themselves back in the wooden spoon zone yet again, so perhaps that is the prod they need. In their last five games they have conceded (on average) more than 32 points per game, and if you exclude the win over the Bulldogs they've been conceding more than 39 points per game. The Tigers defence has been in pretty good shape all season and remains so. With that in mind, it's difficult to imagine the Sea Eagles can score enough points to overcome the amount of points they are likely to let in. It's a numbers game.

Verdict – Tigers by 8

Result – Tigers 22 defeated Sea Eagles 20

New Zealand Warriors vs Penrith Panthers – Friday night – Mt Smart Stadium

Cameron Ciraldo receives a typically challenging introduction to first grade coaching in the NRL. Griffin was replaced on the basis that he was not getting the best out of his team, and the team's performance has slipped since he left. I'm actually tipping them here, which surprises me as much as it will surprise any of you. The Panthers absolutely trounced the Warriors in July, and there are some doubts about both the Warriors halves taking the field. The Warriors can shore up a top eight finish with a win so we'll have a contest here, but I say the Panthers can keep their top four hopes alive.

Verdict – Panthers by 1

Result – Warriors 36 defeated Panthers 16

North Queensland Cowboys vs Parramatta Eels – Friday night – 1300SMILES Stadium

15th plays 16th, but this is the game of the round. The loser (probably) earns a spoon for their troubles, and the loser (probably) is Parramatta. This is the final home game for Jonathan Thurston – no further analysis is needed. Wouldn't you love to be the kid that gets his headgear after this one?

Verdict – Cowboys by 10

Result – Cowboys 44 defeated Eels 6

Canberra Raiders vs South Sydney Rabbitohs – Saturday afternoon – GIO Stadium

A tremendous win by the Raiders last weekend in a high quality game, they beat the team that beat the Bunnies the week before. That looks like good form, and it is, but I'm banking on the probable return of Greg Inglis and Alex Johnston on Saturday, and with those two back the Bunnies bring an attacking left edge that is the best in the business. Should be a ripper.

Verdict – Rabbitohs by 4

Result – Raiders 24 defeated Rabbitohs 12

Gold Coast Titans vs Melbourne Storm – Saturday night – Cbus Super Stadium

The Storm head north looking a little like a heavyweight champion on the ropes. They look ripe for the picking, but landing the killer blow is the challenge. The Eels had their chance last start, but the best they could do is one try from a kick, late in the game, and it took a little bit of magic from Gutherson to get that. Given the logjam of teams near the top of the ladder the Storm will do all they can to stay in the all-important top two. Slater vs Brimson is Old vs New. Brimson is a Brisbane boy by the way, for those of you looking to State of Origins in 2020 and beyond.

Verdict – Storm by 8

Result – Storm 10 defeated Titans 8

Sydney Roosters vs Brisbane Broncos – Saturday night – Allianz Stadium

I don't know what Wayne said to the Broncos at his barbecue (or what the Broncos said to Wayne), but it clearly made a difference. If they can do it again they can win again, but I'm not convinced they can do it again. The Broncos attack has improved in recent weeks but they face the sternest defence in the NRL on Saturday night. Note that Luke Keary is a probable return for the Chooks, and while they lost to the Raiders last weekend it was a high quality game. Plenty of interesting games in round 24, and this is definitely one of them.

Verdict – Roosters by 4

Result – Broncos 22 defeated Roosters 8

Cronulla Sharks vs Newcastle Knights – Sunday afternoon – Southern Cross Group Stadium

When these sides last met the Sharks steam-rolled the Knights in one of the more dominant wins this season. The Sharks forwards just have to repeat what they did then and the two points are theirs for the taking. It's the last game at home for the Sharks this season, and a rowdy crowd can push them home. A significant boost to their points differential wouldn't hurt either.

Verdict – Sharks by 16

Result – Sharks 38 defeated Knights 12

St George Illawarra Dragons vs Canterbury Bulldogs – Sunday afternoon – Jubilee Oval

After round 22 the Dragons dropped out of the top four for the first time this season, and after round 23 they dragged themselves back in again. It was a very good win against a team with everything to play for, and they'll be desperate to keep performing at that sort of level as we head into September. They'll need to get by without Widdop, who should be back in time for the finals. The Bulldogs have won three of their last four, but it's the Red V for me.

Verdict – Dragons by 10

Result – Bulldogs 38 defeated Dragons 0

Wally Lewis - round twenty-four selections (in bold)

Note: tips from Wally will be published on Wednesday night or early Thursday morning.

  • TIGERS vs Sea Eagles
  • WARRIORS vs Panthers
  • COWBOYS vs Eels
  • Raiders vs RABBITOHS
  • Titans vs STORM
  • ROOSTERS vs Broncos
  • SHARKS vs Knights
  • DRAGONS vs Bulldogs

Comments

a's picture

Yeah I have a good feeling to

Mary S's picture

Enjoy the game Hardyards - the atmosphere will be sensational!!!

Steel Panther's picture

Hope to catch at least the second half as I'm off to Mt Smart tonight. I'm wondering if Baggy's BOYS can spoil the party??

Mary S's picture

I sincerely hope not Steel Panther (sorry Baggy). Hope your guys do well tonight at Mt Smart and pull off the win.

Baggy_Gee's picture

That's OK, I won't be on till tomorrow afternoon as that's when I'm watching it. As long as it's a good clean game I'll be happy. Best of luck to all.

mark ashford's picture

Tuisova
Another Roosters supporter...Newbie will be pleased.
Good to hear you are across a variety of sports mate, must keep you busy.

mark ashford's picture

Warriors 12 Panthers 0 with 10 minutes to go before half time.

Mary S's picture

Steel Panther will be ecstatic with the score for Warriors this week!!
2 mins to go & Warriors lead 36/16.

mark ashford's picture

Warriors 36 defeat Gould sorry I mean Panthers 16.
Should put a smile on the dial Steel.

Tuisova's picture

SO you're telling me that the fact that they have realized JT's retiring suddenly make them a good NRL team?

damn, they should have put a" JT's gone" memo on the locker room, they might have made it to the top 8.

Steel Panther's picture

Geez just got home & I see it's 32 zip at half time!!!! You will be smiling too Mary. Where has this been all year?

Mark....the Warriors win tonight puts pressure on your Broncos. Warriors aim now is to try & get a home game 1st week of the finals.

Steel Panther's picture

Geez just got home & I see it's 32 zip at half time!!!! You will be smiling too Mary. Where has this been all year?

Mark....the Warriors win tonight puts pressure on your Broncos. Warriors aim now is to try & get a home game 1st week of the finals.

mark ashford's picture

Tuisova
You gotta remember it's 15 v 16
Cowboys were always going to put it on for Jt's last game in Townsville
I think you're being a bit harsh someone has to win this comp and someone comes last, looks like it won't be the Cows.
Tomorrow night my Broncos are coming to get your Roosters better make sure your team is ready.

mark ashford's picture

Tuisova
Can I say one more thing. If the Cowboys had played all year like they have played in the last 4 weeks they would be well into the 8 if not the 4

mark ashford's picture

Great win by the Cows against Baggy's Eels. Sorry Baggy. But I don't think any of the top 3 teams would have beat the Cows tonight.
Emotion for JT and others carried them through the game.
Great shame they didn't play this way all year or they would be in the top 4. I will miss JT, one of the best ever.

a's picture

Cowboys have avoided the spoon

Mary S's picture

It was brilliant and frustrating to watch the Cowboys (particularly in the first half) in action tonight, and wonder where in the world did their mind-set go this season.

It appeared the team were not only there for JT, but for each other, and played as a cohesive unit for a change.

Yes Steel, I really have a grin from ear to ear at the result tonight - just would have liked the quality of play to have made an appearance earlier in the season!!!

Mary S's picture

Yes Mark,
JT is 'one of a kind' in so many ways.

a's picture

I hate Gus Gould I wish he would sack himself

mark ashford's picture

Hi Mary
Thanks for that link enjoyed the read.
Goulds problem is that he thinks he knows more about RL than the administrators, all the coachs put together, his fellow commentators and anyone else involved in the game.
His great mate Brad Fittler, who has matured and is now an origin winning coach should distance himself from Gus who is a loser.

mark ashford's picture

Hey all Cowboy fans and others does Johnathan Thurstan have the best looking, funny and adorable kids you have seen for a while?
Still smiling after their efforts last night.

mark ashford's picture

Half time Broncs v Roosters. Broncs with a slight lead.
Andrew McCullough gone surely for the rest of the game and maybe next week. Dylan Napa gets a 10 minute rest and is now back on.
Napa has a history of using his head and being a Rooster will probably avoid any suspension. The ref putting him on report was just to appease Bronco fans. He should have been sent off for the game.
Then to hear Gould and Lewis saying "it was just an accident" made me feel sick. Wally Lewis is no longer a Queenslander just another muppet whose money comes from #9

mark ashford's picture

TAD was it an accident when he broke Corbins jaw?
Yes I'm a Qlder and so is Dylan Napper.
The guy has to change his tackle style is all I'm saying.
Now the Broncs have knocked over your best 2 NSW teams and the Storm just got home against the Titans. Time to worry TAD time to worry about where that Trophy may be heading.

a's picture

Broncos have beaten Sharks Rabbitohs and Roosters twice put 50 on the Panthers and beaten NZ in NZ

mark ashford's picture

Thank you "a" for those stats. Gives me some hope coming into the finals.
Sorry Tiger guess that's it for your guys. They have put in an terrific effort this year.

Tailspin's picture

Great game from the Broncos, they look the part coming into finals time.

mark ashford's picture

Wow Dragons in 4th spot blown off the park by the Dogs in or about 13th. Surely Widdop doesn't make that much difference.
Dragons looked tired and disinterested 38/0 is a shameful score for a top 4 team. Bet you Dragons fans are happy about how much you are paying Hunt.

Colin jensen's picture

Pickup your game Wally going beat you he as bad as you get...

Colin jensen's picture

Pickup your game Wally going beat you he as bad as you get...

Steel Panther's picture

Mark that was an absolute hiding. Dragons fan-boy will not be happy!!!

Brad S's picture

Wheels have definitely fallen off the Dragons. Just a little later in the season than in previous years.
"A", you are right, Broncs have played good against top 8 teams this year....except against Melbourne as always. Hopefully can do some damage in the finals and avoid a match up against the Storm.

mark ashford's picture

Colin Jensen....would you please provide a translation of your post if you can. You know just so the rest of us can work out what the hell you are talking about.

mark ashford's picture

Steel & Brad S
The dragon queens robbed me of my only perfect round this year.
Round 25 will be very interesting.

Mary S's picture

A few others missed by 1 this round Mark - bad luck.

A number of injuries this round so yes, Round 25 will be interesting. Knights might beat the Dragons next week with the way the Dragons played today

The Thinker's picture

Greetings football fans

I have updated the NRL ladder and the tipping comp after the end of round 24.

Just like the NRL itself our tipping comp is a tight affair. At least a dozen tipsters are still in contention for a prize this season, and the top gong is well and truly up for grabs.

Top scorers this round were Mark Ashford, Scott M and Taka who all picked 7 from 8...outstanding work from those three.

Last week is the final round of the regular season. Take note that this tipping comp will continue all the way through until the Grand Final. Many tipping comps do not, including the Mark Ashford tipping tipping comp here.

I'll have the round 25 page built shortly, and my previews and tips will be published on Tuesday (although I've lost all form in recent weeks so bah!!!!)

I should also mention that I'm sneaking over the ditch to check out a little patch of New Zealand for the first time...and I'll be taking Ms Thinker and the mini-thinkers with me. I assume they have internet over there, but if my updating of scores and the like is slightly slower than usual please forgive me. I'm probably fending off some native animal I've never met before or out looking for Johnny Ray or something.

All the best

Pages

The latest in NRL news