Round five selections

Manly Sea Eagles vs Brisbane Broncos – Thursday night – Central Coast Stadium

If the NRL season had started two rounds ago, and in many ways it did, the Broncos would be last on the NRL ladder. That's right, on current form, they're going worse than the Dragons. To be fair, the Broncos have faced stiffer opposition than the Dragons, but they're facing stiff opposition here as they take on the team that all but beat the Eels last weekend (and we know what the Eels did to the Broncos). To make it worse, the Broncos have to travel for the first time since the season restart. Maybe, just maybe, the road trip will galvanise the troops. In any case, we see a raft of changes for the away side, with Corey Oates moved into the second row and Ben Te'o thawed out from whatever cryogenic chamber he's been living in for the last decade. Actually, I looked it up, the cryogenic chamber was a stint in rugby, where he racked up 16 tests for England. Not bad for a bloke who was born in Auckland, played league for Samoa, Origin for Queensland, spent 2019 in France and was last seen in Japan. Meanwhile the Sea Eagles are unchanged after their unfortunate/unlucky loss to the Eels. Manly...pick themselves.

Verdict – Sea Eagles by 14

Result – Sea Eagles 20 defeated Broncos 18

New Zealand Warriors vs North Queensland Cowboys – Friday night – Central Coast Stadium

The Warriors round three shutout of the Dragons made most of us smile a little bit, but beating the Dragons doesn't look like strong form at the minute. I'd be curious to know if a team has ever gone from keeping an opponent to 0 in one round to being held to 0 in the next. The Cowboys made plenty of errors against the Sharks but still managed to score 16 points, and if Taumalolo makes the seventeen as suggested they should be winning this.

Verdict – Cowboys by 4

Result – Warriors 37 defeated Cowboys 26

Parramatta Eels vs Penrith Panthers – Friday night – Bankwest Stadium

Two teams still undefeated, and it's a shame we can't have a crowd at Bankwest for this one. The Panthers scored a thumping win in round four on the back of an extra time draw with the only other undefeated team. They're flying under the radar a little while their opponent on Friday night gets all the attention. I'm sure the Panthers don't mind that one bit. We also see the return of Nathan Cleary, who will be keen to atone after his recent exile. The Eels are a short priced favourite, and I suppose they should be, but I'm with the Panthers here in a proper upset.

Verdict – Panthers by 1

Result – Eels 16 defeated Panthers 10

South Sydney Rabbitohs vs Gold Coast Titans – Saturday afternoon – Bankwest Stadium

Not many, if any, saw the Titans winning over the Tigers last start, but it was great that the lads got to sing the team song after an almost year long hibernation. On the back of that you can be sure the Rabbitohs won't take them lightly, and after a string of losses they'll be desperate to atone. Some key returns for the Bunnies in Walker and Roberts - too good I think.

Verdict – Rabbitohs by 18

Result – Rabbitohs 32 defeated Titans 12

Newcastle Knights vs Melbourne Storm – Saturday night – Central Coast Stadium

The Knights squad has the best names - Bradman Best, Herman Ese'ese, Tautau Moga, Tex Hoy...even Ponga is a ripper. Now they're giving me another one in Phoenix Crossland. This team are the gift that keep on giving, and they're the team that keep on winning. They looked comfortable against the Raiders in round four, and the Raiders were comfortable winners over the Storm in round three. I see no reason why the Knights can't win this too. Clearly the bookies disagree with me, but every now and then they look like idiots...and every now and then I don't. Let's hope it's the latter...for a change.

Verdict – Knights by 4

Result – Storm 26 defeated Knights 12

Wests Tigers vs Canberra Raiders – Saturday night – Campbelltown Stadium

Two sides returning from disappointing losses, but clearly Canberra losing to the Knights is stronger form than the Tigers losing to the Titans. Both sides would have been given a serve by their coaches most cranky, and Madge has swung the axe and made changes everywhere. Some handy returns on the bench for the Tigers in Chee-Kam and Packer, but to my eye the Raiders are simply a better side.

Verdict – Raiders by 14

Result – Raiders 14 defeated Tigers 6

Canterbury Bulldogs vs Sydney Roosters – Sunday afternoon – Bankwest Stadium

Just as the Broncos would be last on the ladder had the season started at re-launch, the Chooks would be runaway leaders with a +75 points differential after two games. That's not bad, given they hadn't won a game in 2020 prior, they've played two NRL heavyweights, and Tedesco missed the flight to Brisbane last week. Tedesco should be back here - the club can get him to sit in the drinks esky on the bus to keep his temperature down. The Bulldogs had their first win of the year last round against the Dragons, but beating the Roosters is an entirely different proposition.

Verdict – Roosters by 16

Result – Roosters 42 defeated Bulldogs 6

St George Illawarra Dragons vs Cronulla Sharks – Sunday night – Campbelltown Stadium

In rounds one and two the Dragons weren't terrible, with competitive losses to the Tigers and the Panthers. They weren't winning, but they were competing. I'm not sure what the Dragons did during lockdown, but they clearly haven't readied themselves for the season return. Thus far they've played, without wanting to sound mean, two teams that aren't likely to make the top eight, and they haven't scored a single try. This is harder, and another duck egg beckons.

Verdict – Sharks by 20

Result – Dragons 30 defeated Sharks 16

Wally Lewis - round five selections (in bold)

Note: tips from Wally will be published on Wednesday night or Thursday morning

  • SEA EAGLES vs Broncos
  • Warriors vs COWBOYS
  • EELS vs Panthers
  • RABBITOHS vs Titans
  • Knights vs STORM
  • Tigers vs RAIDERS
  • Bulldogs vs ROOSTERS
  • Dragons vs SHARKS

Comments

The Butcher's picture

Roosters v Bulldogs match postponed till Monday

Baggy_Gee's picture

I think they wanted a closer game in the 4pm game on 9. Maybe they preemptive have applied the slaughter/mercy ruling.

manyana's picture

Attention everyone!! I have just received the following to my inbox.
There are some important schedule changes to the remaining games in Round 5 of the Telstra Premiership.

Today's local derby between the Dragons and the Sharks, originally scheduled for 6:30pm from Campbelltown Stadium, will now kick off at 4:05pm at the same venue.

Today's other clash between the Roosters and the Bulldogs, originally scheduled for 4:05pm, will now be played on Monday 15th June, with a new kick off time of 7pm.

Bulldogs v Roosters game postponed due to 'remote' biosecurity risk

Bulldogs v Roosters game postponed due to 'remote' biosecurity risk
The NRL has postponed Sunday's Canterbury v Sydney Roosters game at Bankwest Stadium until Monday due to ensure player safety in relation to a potential biosecurity problem.

Read More
There are some important schedule changes to the remaining games in Round 5 of the Telstra Premiership.

Today's local derby between the Dragons and the Sharks, originally scheduled for 6:30pm from Campbelltown Stadium, will now kick off at 4:05pm at the same venue.

Today's other clash between the Roosters and the Bulldogs, originally scheduled for 4:05pm, will now be played on Monday 15th June, with a new kick off time of 7pm.

Bulldogs v Roosters game postponed due to 'remote' biosecurity risk

Bulldogs v Roosters game postponed due to 'remote' biosecurity risk
The NRL has postponed Sunday's Canterbury v Sydney Roosters game at Bankwest Stadium until Monday due to ensure player safety in relation to a potential biosecurity problem.

Read More

tigerholic's picture

The Butcher trying to win sympathy votes by being nice to some of the other big names on this site.

I am pretty sure that no one likes being called names like dumb and dumber or tweedle dee and tweedle dum, how did you get my school report to find out that I was a dumb arse at school.
I hope you can stand the attacks Butcher, its a long way to the finish line.

Disappointing to see the Roosters/Dogs game postponed until tomorrow, was looking forward to seeing Tedesco running around again terrorising at the back end off each half..

Have a great remainder of the weekend Butcher and everyone else. Currently raining here in Laidley which is most welcome.

Tiger

The Butcher's picture

Tiger nice to hear from you
I’m sure you weren’t a dumb arse because you are definitely a smart arse
But let’s talk about dumb.
Your coach Michael Maguire got it wrong, you don’t drop your best attacking and inspirational player when you play a top team. Why didn’t he drop him to the bench to send a message and then rotate him with the other halves. You should be proud of your team they had a go.Oh by the way Packer cost you big time another strategy that back fired.
Your probably getting the cowboys at a good time next week I think your halves have the edge on there’s
Enjoy Tedesco.

BigPeteBx's picture

Gr8 to see rain at Laidley for you Tiger.
I must touch base with the couple of guys near you, that I know.

Yeah mate - the rescheduled match would have been good to watch, as both teams have rock hard forwards. Napa against his old club, would have no doubt been a clash.
Although Drags might just happen to lift themselves this arvo, but Cronulla a bit smarter around the backline. Not sure if a boy from here gets a start, or on the bench, as he's been setting the place alight from fullback.

Cheers and enjoy your Sunday arvo.
Big Pete

Christine's picture

I just read broncos have signed izzac luke from saints so how will gbey go noe guys bad move or not your call open the discussion who ever has an opinion mark what do you think...

Christine's picture

Jannel 9msn homepage has an article about broncos getting rid of mc cullough to now sign iizzac luke it doesn'take sense broncos recrutment what are they doing rocket , mark , thinket did you guys know that was coming at all ???

Steel Panther's picture

Getting rid of McCullough & signing Luke does seem strange. Luke well past his best. He was poor at the Warriors after a stellar career at the Bunnies.

What do you think Christine, after all Isaac is one of your favourite players.

Baggy_Gee's picture

Their on song tonight JK_Bubble. Finally hitting their straps after giving Luke the Boot.

Christine's picture

Was steel was he has too have the right coach to bring out the best in him other wise he is lazy gets complacent i don't know when it is affective from if it is for the rest of the year or if it is starting next season or even how long he has been signed for & i haven't seen it anywhere else as yet only on nine msn homepage thats why i asked the ? to see if anyone else knew anything yes when luke first started out playing i did rate him better than what i do now but we all age even foran was better when he used to play in new zealand with izzac luke toughter they were good but things change we can't stay young forever & foran has made al ot of mistakes too over the years , when izzac luke left souths & went to new zealand he didn't play as well but the way i have heard it before good players go to new zealand & become bad players & bad players go to storm & become good players so it really does depend on the coach which brings me too my next ? How long will seibold survive at broncos until they get rid of him ?

Steel Panther's picture

Your are right about player movements going to NZ & Storm Christine. I understand Luke has left the Dragons effectively immediately and is now a Bronco. He was lazy & often out of condition when in NZ.

Christine's picture

Yes steel he put a lot of weight on not necessarily in the right places he was out of condition fat for izzac he just serm to loose the drive he had a souths under maguire at the time he had when he was there but then a lot of players say maguire expects a lot from his players trains them hard i know that from when i was a souths member TAD use to say the same maguire has a rep for it pushing his players as much as he can to the point they want out ...

Christine's picture

Thanks foe the confirmation on that steel ...

Dragons-fanboy's picture

Oh when the Saints go marching in! Such a great feeling that the boys got off the duck egg! Great win from the Dragons! They actually played some footy today and outplayed the Sharks!

Dragons-fanboy's picture

If only I tipped the boys this week, I guess I should tip against the Dragons more often ;P

JKBubble's picture

Thanks Baggy,
I actually made it through the whole 80 mins without a refill...couldn't leave the screen. Time to make up for it now....been a long time coming!
Have to say i like marys changes this week....Hunt to 9, Mccinnes to 13, frizzell to right side.
JKBubble

Christine's picture

Jk bubble how safe is mary mc gregors job now surely 1win can't secure his future ...

mark ashford's picture

First
Congrats to the Dragons for their first win. Watched the game and they were dominate, where have they been until now.
For those who have a short memory Padbul took his name from Paula Abdul who was a favourite of his. Not sure where he has gone.
As for TAD the annoying devil not sure where he is either.

JKBubble's picture

Christine,
I don't believe it's very safe...i reckon the ship has already sailed and 1 win isn't going to save his job.

tigerholic's picture

Afternoon All
Wests Tigers release Corey Thompson effective immediately. Another top player we let go that will probably prosper.

Thanks for your service to the Tigers Corey, was a pleasure having you in Tiger colours.

Tiger

BigPeteBx's picture

Evening Mark - interesting how these rounds are starting out and ending.
Yes, correct both you and Christine with Pabdul.
They (PAB & TAD - nice blokes with humour and sarcasm) are most likely about and walking among us - not over us.
Keep well - Big Pete

Christine's picture

Big pete are you in contact with pabdul of the site if so can yoi make contact & see about getting bim back on here i know you
two meet up i thought you may have exchanged no 's or email address & ig my memory seves me Correctly which it usually does the reason for his name was he went to a concert with his wife & people were asking for her autograph because they thought she was paula abdul hence the saying pabdul pabdul your wife looks like paula abdul & it just stuck i do remember him saying something about that big pete anyway worth a shot if we get pabdul back on here he is a character worth a laugh ...

JKBubble's picture

this scoreline is getting ugly

Baggy_Gee's picture

It was pretty ugly at 0-0. Did they pull the entire first grade from the field at the 28th minute mark?

mark ashford's picture

Isaac Luke was a tough little hooker who seems to have lost some interest. Just what we need at the Broncs another player who has lost interest. Who knows maybe Siebold can get something out of him. He's signed for the remainder of the season at a reduced rate. He has to watch his weight and fitness levels.
Katoni Staggs out for 4 weeks with hammy strain, Broncs don't get too many breaks.

Baggy_Gee's picture

Its all about attitude, he may come with a rocket under him. But it does seem like a done and dusted season for your boys Mark.

mark ashford's picture

Baggy
Yes Isaac Luke may bring something to the club with Durden injured. McCullough was let go to make way for Durden (the next big thing) but he's out for a few weeks so "welcome" Isaac. We face the inform Knights next weekend with 4 xBroncs in their team out to prove something. You face the Roosters who are on fire....good luck.

Christine's picture

Tiger corey has signed with titans see how long that lasts he might end up begging to come back to tigers yet well see ...

Baggy_Gee's picture

Yeah if we can stay with or beat the Roosters we will be genuinely a chance to win the whole deal. If they blow us off the park we might have to wait till next year, but we will see. Bring it on.

BigPeteBx's picture

Evenin Christine - sorry, Pabdul honestly never left me any contact details and I'm not in private communication with him. TAD neither, although I was close to meeting TAD on an occasion, where he expressed interest in meeting up. I've only met one person from this site, so far, but he is a bit tied up lately.

Pabdul did mention the Paula Abdul bit here and I'm very impressed you kept that in memory. Maybe in some ways, he's now following World Wide Wrestling. He will be impressed tonight like The Butcher, in the manner that Chooks dismantled Dogs.
Kyle Flanagan kicked well - 7 from 7 and comes from the background of the other football (round ball) code.

Keep well - maybe Thinker can prod a few ribs of Pabdul's off his past registered email address and ask how he is going, on behalf of all of us here.
Big Pete

mark ashford's picture

Big Pete
Yes the Roosters dismantled the Dogs tonight but seriously it was like top playing the bottom. I'm really looking forward to Roosters-V-Eels this weekend, will sort out who is a serious contender.

The Butcher's picture

Mark your still awake!
The Roosters are 6th on the ladder and are favourites to win the comp at $4.50 we know their a contender it’s the Eels who need to show where their at when they play them.
The dragons have got off to great starts in recent years then they’ve met a top side and gone downhill so until they get thru the next 2 weeks we won’t know

The Butcher's picture

Big Pete
I reckon thinker should try to contact pabdul and then I can see if anything arrives in my inbox?

BigPeteBx's picture

Hey Larry/Butcher - Thinker would know who he was sending to and you'd quite well know, not to be expecting.

Anyways, not a good weekend in AFL, for the Pabdul.
Round 6 NRL, should be a good matchup with Eels, but I feel the way Chooks like this revised rules and play, they'll most likely come out on top.
Cheers and keep well
Big Pete

BigPeteBx's picture

Correct there Mark - whatever, it'll be fast paced and being a Saturday game won't be on free-to-air.

Cheers and keep well - Big Pete

Pages

The latest in NRL news