Penrith Panthers vs Sydney Roosters – Thursday night – CommBank Stadium
First plays second in a pre-cursor to what we might expect in September. The Panthers have been a little wobbly of late, losing 4 of their last 7. Mind you, they had such a mid-season lead they could afford some wobbles, and are still on top of the ladder. Quirky stat - those four losses were all to sides based outside NSW. The Chooks are one team they never seem to have much trouble with, winning 12 of the last 13, including a 40-4 win back in round three. Despite the overwhelming head to head statistics, I can make a case for the Roosters to spring a minor upset. Tedesco returns to bolster a team that's been winning anyway, and their seven-game winning streak includes victories over some in-form opponents (Bulldogs, Cowboys, Knights, Sharks). They'll need to be on, but if we get the version of the Chooks that racked up more than 80 points against the Cowboys they'll beat anyone. Only three teams have scored more than 20 points against the Panthers all season, so they can't run away with this, but with Edwards, McLean, Kenny and Yeo unavailable for the home side I think the Chooks can sneak a confidence-building win here.
Verdict - Roosters by 2
Result - Roosters 12 defeated Panthers 6
Manly Sea Eagles vs Redcliffe Dolphins – Friday night – 4 Pines Park
A run of outs for the Sea Eagles has them outside the top eight and with next to no prospects of getting back in. Mind you, they have a good record against the Dolphins, and tore them to pieces earlier this season in Redcliffe. Faulolo returns at fullback, but the loss of Paseka up front leaves their engine room short on revs. By contrast, the Dolphins interchange is likely to be Plath, Stone, Gilbert and Kaufusi. The Dolphins backline gets lots of the headlines, but they can win this with their middle. A top four finish, while unlikely, isn't impossible for the Dolphins, and that carrot should see them fired up.
Verdict - Dolphins by 8
Result - Dolphins 22 defeated Sea Eagles 0
Canterbury Bulldogs vs South Sydney Rabbitohs – Friday night – Accor Stadium
The most important game of the round I say, with the winner likely to make the top eight and the loser likely to fall just short. Particularly so for the 9th placed Bulldogs. with a precarious points differential but an easier run into the finals than the Bunnies. Tupouniua is out and he's a big loss, but the Bulldogs are a better proposition now that Kikau and Preston are in the back row. They've now won 6 of their last 8, and were a touch unlucky against the Chooks in round 23. The Bunnies have lost Ward and Humphries, but Graham is back and his contests with Rinakama could be crucial. On Good Friday, the Bunnies prevailed over the Dogs 32 to 24. On that day, Mitchell was having one of those games, and Crichton went off with an arm injury that he still seems to be managing through the season. Importantly, the Bulldogs are playing much better now than they were then, and I think they can turn the tables.
Verdict - Bulldogs by 4
Result - Rabbitohs 22 defeated Bulldogs 6
Cronulla Sharks vs Canberra Raiders – Saturday afternoon – Ocean Protect Stadium
A stumble from the Sharks last week against the team that will almost certainly win the spoon this season. In doing so, they've left the door ajar for the Dolphins to potentially sneak their way into the top four. They'll need to bounce back and probably will, particularly at this venue where they rarely lose. As far as away venues go, this one is perhaps the least popular. Given the Raiders season is effectively over, there's some chance they don't show up in the right mindset on Saturday. If they did turn up, I'd give them some chance, particularly with Fonua-Blake out for the home side. They've also lost Ramien but Iro is back in the centres, and he's no slouch.
Verdict - Sharks by 7
Result - Raiders 24 defeated Sharks 20
Parramatta Eels vs North Queensland Cowboys – Saturday night – CommBank Stadium
The Cowboys last away game of the regular season, but a win against the Eels on Saturday night locks the Cowboys in as a 2026 finalist. Not bad for a team many were predicting could finish last this year. Just the one change for the away side, with Mahoney returning at dummy-half and Luke starting on the interchange. Iongi is the key casualty for the Eels, with Twidle coming in at fullback for the home side. The Eels have already beaten the Cowboys once this season (33-30 in Townsville), and the Cowboys record against the Eels and at this ground is woeful. But the return of Mahoney will tighten the Cowboys up in the middle and I can't see how the Eels can score enough points to win this. Across their last three victories, the Eels scored just 54 points, and those were all against teams that aren't going well (Raiders, Sea Eagles, Tigers). The Cowboys have too much to play for and they can get it done.
Verdict - Cowboys by 4
Result - Eels 32 defeated Cowboys 30
Brisbane Broncos vs New Zealand Warriors – Saturday night – Suncorp Stadium
There's some chance this could be the second game in a row where the Broncos are playing at their home ground but have less than half of the crowd support. They now find themselves in second last position, and could now (mathematically at least) end up running last. It's quite a downfall for a defending premier, and it's hard to find an excuse - eleven of the players lining up on Saturday played in the grand final last year. On paper they could win this, but we could have said that most weeks and it's just not happening. The Warriors couldn't have been more impressive last start against the Panthers. Metcalf slotted into the halves like he'd been there all season. They're playing with confidence and they're playing attractive rugby league. No wonder they've captured the hearts and minds of much of New Zealand and the hefty chunk of ex-pats living over here. Looks a high-scoring contest and a great night out...if you're a Warriors fan.
Verdict - Warriors by 14
Result - Warriors 40 defeated Broncos 6
Newcastle Knights vs Gold Coast Titans – Sunday afternoon – McDonald Jones Stadium
With winnable games at home and a bye up their sleeve, the Knights will likely end up playing at home in the first week of the finals - a terrific result for the club under their new coach. He gets to take on his old team on Sunday. Best and Crossland return to bolster a team that's been winning, and I expect they can win again. The Titans are clearly a team on the rise but this might be one of those games that gets away from them.
Verdict - Knights by 20
Result - Knights 36 defeated Titans 26
Wests Tigers vs St George Illawarra Dragons – Sunday afternoon – CommBank Stadium
Dragons fans haven't had a lot to cheer about...for years really, but the win over the Sharks was terrific and with the roster they are assembling for next season they look a legitimate top eight prospect next year. They'll take confidence out of the last start win, and adding another Couchman to their line-up on Sunday doesn't hurt them one bit. The Tigers have had an extra week to prepare and bring a classy spine to the contest, but the Dragons have them beaten for depth across the paddock and I think they pick up another two points here. An even contest, and it could end up being one of the games of the round.
Verdict - Dragons by 2
Result - Dragons 24 defeated Tigers 22
Wally Lewis - round twenty-four selections (in bold)
Note: tips from Wally will be published on Wednesday night or Thursday morning
- PANTHERS vs Roosters
- Sea Eagles vs DOLPHINS
- BULLDOGS vs Rabbitohs
- SHARKS vs Raiders
- Eels vs COWBOYS
- Broncos vs WARRIORS
- KNIGHTS vs Titans
- TIGERS vs Dragons

Comments
Submitted by The Thinker on
Greetings football fans
For the first time in a long time we have teams on equal points at the top of the NRL ladder. And we have a new leader in our tipping comp in Elizabeth. Plenty of solid tipping results despite a few upset results, with a handful of us getting 7 from 8. No-one found the Dragons, including Dragons-fanboy who would have picked a perfect round if he did. Hard to find though. As always, if you notice any issues with the scoring just let me know.
I'll have my previews and selections published on Wednesday this week.
All the best
The Thinker
Submitted by Dragons-fanboy on
Yeah I can’t believe of all teams that costed me my perfect round it was the Dragons! That’ll do me, but honestly I don’t mind one bit as it was an amazing win against all odds!
Cheers!!!!
Submitted by Buzz105 on
Looks like Teddy has an ankle injury and is out for tonights game
Submitted by BigPeteBx on
Thanks N P - I saw it also last night but was waiting to see final teams when they show up this arve. Keep well - be nicer weather where u r.
BigPete
Submitted by MGM on
Hey Steely!
I just saw your very polite version of me in last week's Comments.
.Hahaha :-)
That howler where Donohue was offside was a clear winner in a round choc full of misses, inconsistencies and the usual bucket load of tries scored off forward passes..
... An interesting fact about the two matches that you highlighted -
.. The bunker official was the same for both of them , and I'll give you just one guess who it was ......... grrrrrr.
Submitted by RyzPaz on
Can’t believe how many people tipping dolphins. Looks like just you and I on the might eagles Pete. Something about dolphins that makes manly shine. Desperate for a win…Friday night at home…”upset” of the round 😉 🦅
Submitted by Mary S on
What a hell of a game to watch tonight - almost like Origin!!
Cheers,
Mary
Submitted by BigPeteBx on
G'day Ryz - you nailed it Champ. I think Lilly as in Lillychino has selected Manly as well. Playing at home and one of our once faithful followers David has tipped against them - dont blame him the way they've been going of late. What a disgraceful showing in front of the former legends at last home game. There has to be improvement!
If there is hope there is a chance for 8th position but then the equations will come into play with 4/against. This year hasnt been one of my tipping highlights but we keep going. With a player name like RyzPaz I assume u r a Storm follower or you live in Melb.
Let me know as I used to keep tabs with a couple of tippers in this group. Several have flew the coop but couple are still here. Then our Summer rolls around and we have Big Bash Cricket and also UK EPL if you follow soccer of old with A-League to the mix.
Cheers and keep well - BigPete in Bx Country.
Submitted by Esra Star on
Is Billy stepping aside so he can step in to replace Belly ache?
Submitted by RyzPaz on
Ha! No not Melbourne, I’m a true Novocastrian born and bred 👍 and the name is a combo of first and last name. Always had a soft spot for manly. Love the way they are spreading the ball tonight. Hopefully big O can use his horsepower to steam roll a few times 😃👍 thighs the size of my beer belly! HA! I tipped on and off in here over the years, not doing so well this year. Enjoy mate! ✌️ 🍻
Submitted by BigPeteBx on
Gr8 to hear Ryz. Small world indeed. My wife strongly supports Knights as does her N/Castle and Singleton family. Yes mate, Manly had a few players from there play with them like Chooks and Eagles exchanged over the years. Ben Kennedy one of my faves from yours.
Taumalolo has a pair of oak tree thighs that are hard to get around - so your "middle-age" spread isnt an issue.
Got The Community Shield on this weekend from UK(soccer), then the comp proper kicks off next week. I coached soccer in Bx for 29yrs, worked with NSWGR prior to NSW Education and was fortunate enough to se the 99th FA Cup at the former Wembley many years ago. Must go but the lads are getting another lesson tonight.
A close family friend at Bribie Island was telling me that Farnsworth comes into their shop. We had two tippers here lived at the same place.
Keep well Champ - BigPete.
Submitted by Rocket Ryan on
Everyone on this site knows how i feel about Referee Klien watch the try he disallowed last night when he got in the way and just let that sink in.
Submitted by Steel Panther on
Rocket,
You can't blame Klein for this one mate. Crichton moved towards him in the complete opposite direction to the oncoming ball carrier. It was a dispicable act as he knew connection with the ref would result in a no try. Players who accidently bump into refs get suspended yet there is no doubt this is a deliberate act. Surely he gets called up by the match review committee?
Klein had already done his damage the night before from the bunker.