Round twenty five selections

Melbourne Storm vs Penrith Panthers – Thursday night – AAMI Park

The Storm aren't likely to make the top eight, but they definitely fall short if they can't win on Thursday. This is also their last game of the season at home, and they'll want to give their fans something to cheer about before the long off-season. They also have an incredible record over the Panthers at this ground, winning nine of their last ten, and the return of Grant makes a world of difference. That's a fair list of reasons why the Storm could win this, and they could, but it's hard to ignore the round five result where the Panthers beat them 50-10. The Panthers aren't exactly humming right now, losing five of their last eight. They were all but locked in as minor premiers, and now they run the very real risk of dropping out of the top two. That would likely mean an away game in the first week of the finals, against one of the teams that have beaten them in the last fortnight. They'll want to avoid that, and it's reason enough to tip them here. Alomoti is out with a hamstring injury, but his replacement (McLean) is more than handy. And it's the game of the round.

Verdict - Panthers by 7

Result - Panthers 22 defeated Storm 14

Canberra Raiders vs Brisbane Broncos – Friday night – GIO Stadium

The 2025 minor premiers vs the 2025 premiers - 12th plays 16th. Seems hard to process, but here we are. The Raiders, much like the Storm, need to just keep winning and maybe (maybe) sneak into the top eight. For the Broncos, they need to win something or run the risk of running last. Of their last three games, this is likely the hardest. The injury to Walsh doesn't make any of this any easier. The Raiders welcome back Sasagi and Horsburgh, who plays his last game at home in a Raiders jersey. He'll wish to make amends. It's also the last game at home in any jersey for Papalii as he has announced his retirement from the game. Given that, the Raiders should be ready to run through walls and get the win here. Providing the occasion doesn't overwhelm them, they should win and win well.

Verdict - Raiders by 14

Result - Broncos 34 defeated Raiders 30

Redcliffe Dolphins vs Parramatta Eels – Friday night – Suncorp Stadium

Congratulations to the mighty Redcliffe Dolphins, who play their first finals series this season. In something of a sliding doors moment in time, the Dolphins have won their last seven games at Suncorp Stadium. That run of wins includes victories over the top two teams. Meanwhile, the Broncos have lost eight in a row at their 'spiritual home'. I don't expect Brisbane to become a sea of red and white as a result, but they'll have a few extras cheering for them in September. Lemuelu is out for the home side, with Plath coming into the starting thirteen. De Belin returns for the Eels and Walker succumbs to a wrist injury. The Eels have won two of their last four, and been competitive against top eight teams over the last month. That's good enough to make this a contest, but the Dolphins have edged their way into the top four and I'm sure they'd like to keep it that way.

Verdict - Dolphins by 4

Result - Dolphins 34 defeated Eels 16

Newcastle Knights vs Manly Sea Eagles – Saturday afternoon – McDonald Jones Stadium

It's the last game of the regular season for the Knights at home, and I expect they'll pack the joint unless the weather is abominable.  If I'm saying the Storm and Raiders are still some chance of making the top eight, I have to accept that the Sea Eagles could make it too, but they're not playing like it. They do add two Trbojevic brothers to their starting thirteen on Saturday - perhaps that's the catalyst that can turn things around. Faulolo moves from fullback to the halves to replace the injured Walsh. The Knights will be without Gagai and the exciting youngster Manuleleua, but Best and Saifiti return to a team in form. I expect the Knights will win and win well. Fingers crossed that Tom Trbojevic gets through the game without issue.

Verdict - Knights by 14

Result - Sea Eagles 44 defeated Knights 24

South Sydney Rabbitohs vs New Zealand Warriors – Saturday night – Accor Stadium

The Warriors are still flying high but they can't afford to lose any more playmakers - Metcalf joins Boyd and Martin on the casualty list, with Nicoll-Klokstad suspended until the final round of the regular season. Hansen is the new name in the halves in just his second NRL game. Notably his debut was solid - another prospect there. For the Rabbitohs, Mitchell has been named on an extended bench but he's unlikely to get the call up yet. The Bunnies win over the Bulldogs was solid enough but they have lost four of their last five against top eight teams (and that one win was by two points). The Warriors are a level above that, even with injuries to key players. A potential top two finish is so valuable to the Warriors and while that's within reach I can't see them taking this lightly. 

Verdict - Warriors by 4

Result - Warriors 45 defeated Rabbitohs 26

St George Illawarra Dragons vs Canterbury Bulldogs – Saturday night – Allianz Stadium

You have to go all the way back to the very first game of the season for the last time these sides met. That Las Vegas opener was a little bit mad - locked up at 14-all at full time, the Dragons had four (yes, four) unsuccessful field goal attempts before Crichton sealed a one-point win for the Bulldogs in the 89th minute. It's been a fairly grim season for the Dragons since then, but with a new coach, some big signings for next season, and some green shoots on the paddock in recent weeks, their fans have legitimate reasons to be optimistic about the not-too-distant future. If they can win this (and they can) they are a very real prospect of offloading the wooden spoon to the 2025 premiers...so something to play for. No changes for to the seventeen for the home side. For the Bulldogs, Rinakama has succumbed to not one but two injuries. Tuala shifts to the wing and Xerri comes into the starting thirteen in the centres. After successive losses, the Bulldogs find themselves in 9th place and needing results to fall their way to improve on that position. Given the Cowboys have a bye that won't be happening this week. But they simply need to win, and while the Dragons are absolutely in this game up to their ears, the Dogs should find this slightly easier than recent outings. It might not be the best game this round, but it could be the most important.

Verdict - Bulldogs by 1

Result - Bulldogs 44 defeated Dragons 14

Gold Coast Titans vs Cronulla Sharks – Sunday afternoon – CBus Super Stadium

Another game where the last match-up was in round one, and it was a day to forget for the Titans who conceded the dreaded half century in their first game of the year. They're clearly going better now...thankfully. Hau returns to the starting thirteen, and he's one of many bright prospects on the Titans roster. Onward and upward. Just as I started to believe in the Sharks they wobbled to successive losses againts teams outside the top eight. Before that, they'd won four in a row against top eight teams, so they're not an easy mob to get a read on. The injury to Trindall doesn't help their finals prospects one bit, but his absence is the sort of thing that will bring Hynes to life. It won't surprise me if he has a big game and steers them to victory on Sunday. Another loss here, and they can probably say goodbye to any hope of a top four finish. 

Verdict - Sharks by 13

Result - Sharks 30 defeated Titans 22

Sydney Roosters vs Wests Tigers – Sunday afternoon – Allianz Stadium

If the bookies are to be trusted (and they're not) this game has already been run and won. The Roosters are, by my recollection, the shortest priced team here of any NRL game all season. And they should be. Tedesco is back, and they are on track to claim the minor premiership. Only two regular first graders are unavailable for the Chooks (Crichton and Tupou) and they both are expected to return next week. Everything is coming together when it matters most. As for the Tigers, they have nothing to lose...but they will lose.

Verdict - Roosters by 30

Result - Tigers 25 defeated Roosters 24

Wally Lewis - round twenty-five selections (in bold)

Note: tips from Wally will be published on Wednesday night or Thursday morning

  • Storm vs PANTHERS
  • RAIDERS vs Broncos
  • DOLPHINS vs Eels
  • KNIGHTS vs Sea Eagles
  • Rabbitohs vs WARRIORS
  • Dragons vs BULLDOGS
  • Titans vs SHARKS
  • ROOSTERS vs Tigers

Comments

The Thinker's picture

Greetings football fans

I have updated the NRL ladder and the tipping comp after round 24. A new leader on the NRL ladder for the first time in a long time, and they have a 2 point lead on the other minor premiership contenders. A tough round of tipping - congrats to shotfromthehip and Bundy Bear who top scored with 6 from 8.

As always, if you notice any issues with the scoring just let me know.

We are having an issue with the tipping form on our round 25 page. My little helper is crawling around in the engine room hoping to sort that our for us as soon as possible.

I'll have my previews and selections published on Wednesday.

All the best

The Thinker

Thinker's Little Helper's picture

I've hit the side of the server with several hammers and I am pretty sure the hamsters have woken up again and the tipping form should be working now. Have a great round, all.

Esra Star's picture

Bloody hamsters.

MGM's picture

Watching tonight.
The NRL has a serious problem.
It's a dereliction of duty problem and it's across the board.
Forward passes have become RIDICULOUSLY PROMINENT and unpunished.
Tonight's game is confirmation for me that I was right to detach myself from my investment in this game.
... I say "across the board" because EVERYBODY is to blame!
.. Not just the match officials who are just Fu(king blind to it , you sideline @ssholes especially , but EVERYONE!
.. the NRL is ultimately the one to blame.
.. They are instructing the officials to not slow down the game.
But if you love the game and have the whistle ... SHAME ON YOU for not BLOWING THAT THING!

Coaches especially tell their players to Push the envelope because "we need to get an advantage from the fact that they don't pull us up" and the players naturally obey those instructions.
.. But you are ALL to blame for this Fu(king Fiasco !!!

Steely , That's an MGM rant!

BigPeteBx's picture

Indeed it is MGM (and I'm not Steely) - its a miracle from Mike and The Mechanics mate. U know what I mean!
Hang about here Champ - as I get the time I read many comments about the game. Once had a fellow Fortress Eagle and he sure made his feelings felt as well. Many leave us here but I guess they find the time to look in on occasions.
On a brighter note - UK EPL 1st Round this weekend, so I guess u r riding Liverpool home.
Take care - Big Pete (V8's/Supercars also nearing here)☺

Steel Panther's picture

Hey Big Pete,
Hope you are well my good friend. You're a bit more quiet on here like myself. I'm still following the footy closely, averaging watching at least 7 games most weekends but disillusioned by the officiating. Manly not travelling too well this season unlike my local team. I still think Penrith will be there at the pointy end of the season.

Talking of not travelling well, poor seasons had by Liverpool & Rangers and Rangers already off to a bad start this year. Hope Liverpool manage to do better this EPL season, new coach and all.

Take care mate! Canberra v Brisbane has just kicked off

MGM's picture

Hiya Pete , nice to hear from you.
Hope you're enjoying all the ball games , even though none of our teams are doing great atm :-(
I'm always riding "the 'Pool" even when I'm not watching.
Hope Steely's right about the new coach!
. Cheers mate.

MGM's picture

P.S.
Speaking of those that have left .... it would be nice to hear from Newbie from Perth since his team is doing so well this season.
B'Gerk , B'Gerk !

BigPeteBx's picture

Had heaps on Steely - reason for not too much typing/convo's. Most to do with local sports. Where I administrate in with a few things going with funding etc. Plus volunteer work I do.
I only get to view Free-to-Air matches. Every one of the Pay ones has something different, so I I thought bugger it to dish out for all of them and not get to do too much viewing. A waste of otherwise Champ. Plus missus would think I have too much spare time..hahaha.
But Manly - total embarrassment this season. Next question.

Hope we can have a bit of a chat through Thinker pause of seasons to see how it's going. Maybe others here might like to as well. Big Bash Cricket will get me in once it bats/bowls off - not kick. Our National team didn't start too brilliant and then they let B/desh give them a trouncing on our home soil in Croc Country.
I'll push on buddy - keep well - BigPete.

BigPeteBx's picture

Nice to catch up again MGM - always a few sports matches to like during the busy season. Manly v Eels had better times back in 1980's BUT whatever, we all here have our faves whether they go good or fall over.
It'll be one to watch as well as to who gets the first sacking in EPL.
Gunners have set the benchmark to start the season - will be interesting for them.
Then all the leagues and cup matches start and then we see who has to most depth to handle it.
Cheers and keep well. Clocking off very soon!!!
BigPete.

BigPeteBx's picture

Dont know MGM about Newbie - he was contemplating going to Thailand to retire. Nice place but spicy food. Gardens and meadows seem always green. I also did the Bridge on River Kwai trip one day.
Ever want to teach anyone to drive - Bangkok in peak hour or after work when its pouring rain. Stuff a goanna - bedlam travelling on a bus just watching the light show (lightning).

Newbie would be over the world with his beloved Arsenal in UK winning Community Shield to kick this year off. Plus he'd be crowing for Sydney Roosters at present - like a few that were once here and flew the coop.
Must go - Cheers and keep well!
Big Pete.

Bronco Legend's picture

Should have stayed loyal and picked my Broncs for their untidy but great win tonight against the Raiders i am so happy, its taken a while.
Rocket Ryan stayed loyal and gets the points.
Wont finish as wooden spooners, but still not a good season.
Cheers all from Bronco Legend.

BigPeteBx's picture

I now know that feeling B/Legend.
Our boys had the Opium take affect up in N/castle. Have been very dismal quite a bit this year and cost me in tipping, although Sharks, Dogs and Raiders have also done similar. Sure has been a mixed bag tipping comp this year - nothing like a change I guess.
Keep well Legend - c u on the surfboards - BigPete

Bronco Legend's picture

Well done this evening to the West Tigers what a great win, Tigerholic will be very happy with the result and will be celebrating, what a big upset, if Roosters won tonight they would have been on top of the table. Going to be an unpredictable grand final i think.
Cheers Bronco Legend

tigerholic's picture

Evening Tipsters
I am very happy with the result, when the commentators were saying this could be one of the biggest upsets, I knew it was way too early to dream.

My son who now follows the Tigers with me and I were dreading the game as with many league fans, we too thought it would have been 100-0.

I won't stand for anyone to say that the Roosters were off their game today and that's the only reason the Tigers won.

What I watched was a team who finally showed what they could have all year but lost their mojo.

No finals again but todays win was a shot in the arm for us diehard Tigers fans.

Thanks Bronco Legend, I also tipped the Broncos to upset the Raiders along with Rocket Ryan and a few others.

Have a great week folks, Tiger and his better half are off to Cairns on Wednesday for a birthday party on Saturday.

Tiger

Rocket Ryan's picture

Tiger Tiger Tiger,to force a child to follow the Tigers is straight out child abuse,the Roosters like the rest of Australia rated the Tigers as no threat.

Mary S's picture

Hi Tiger,
A great result for all Tiger fans with the win today, as was the win for all Broncos and Sea Eagles fans. Frustrating in a way, I'm sure, to wonder why your team wasn't able to play like that more often through the season.
Enjoy your trip to Cairns

Cheers,
Mary

Mary S's picture

So good to have comments coming in from you all this week - from hampsters, rants, EPL and Big Bash and wondering how Newbie is getting on - I do miss his comments and"Song of the Week".

@ Big Pete
Do you ever get any news from Baggy Gee or Mark Ashton?

Good luck everyone in tipping next week's winners, in a season where it seems more coplicated each round!!

Cheers,
Mary

BigPeteBx's picture

Hello Miss Mary - nice to see an exchange tween us.
Agree with the each round complicated. Heya Teach - complicated☺

No word on Baggy Gee - I think he was into studies or something last we heard from him on Thinker site.

Mark Ashford had moved from Bribie Island back to G/Coast I thought, from one of his last posts he made to us all. Not sure if he was suffering ill health then or that was the reason to relocate as I think he had a daughter down that way.
Christine was another who seems to have gone extra quiet.

Maybe Thinker can drop them a Bcc line and say we have been asking about them. Well, they were long time tippers here.

You take care Mary and keep well - Big Pete.

Mary S's picture

Hi Big Pete,
Thanks for the update/

Yes, noticed my spelling error (complicated) just as my comment was waving bye-bye and going on its merry way!!

Cheers,
Mary

The latest in NRL news