Round three selections

Melbourne Storm vs Penrith Panthers – Thursday night – AAMI Park

For the team chasing an astonishing fifth consecutive premiership, some doubts were raised about the Panthers last week against an under-strength Roosters line-up. There are no excuses for that loss - they were simply outplayed on the night. Granted, they still found a way to turn the game into a contest in the final moments, but there's no escaping the fact that the team conceded 38 points, more points than they have conceded in any game in the previous four seasons. Now they have to dust themselves off and travel to Melbourne to take on a Storm line-up that have had nearly two weeks to prepare for this. Nelson Asofa-Solomona is back from a suspension that kept him out of the grand final last year, but he's not likely to make the seventeen. Notably, the Storm haven't had to leave home this year, unlike their opponents who might still be overcoming a Vegas hangover. For the Panthers, Dylan Edwards is out and replaced by Daine Laurie - a terrific replacement fullback, but he's not Dylan Edwards. Only a fool would write off the Panthers after one poor game, and while I show far too many moments of idiocy, I'm not a complete imbecile. I'm sure they'll improve, and I wouldn't be surprised if they won, but I can't tip them. In a round with plenty of intriguing contests, this is likely to be the best of them.

Verdict – Storm by 4

New Zealand Warriors vs Sydney Roosters – Friday night – Go Media Stadium

Important victories for both clubs last week - the Warriors gave their fans at home something to believe in and the Chooks surprised almost everybody with a win over the Panthers. Rugby League will never stop surprising you. The Chooks haven't lost in Auckland since 2017 and have won their last eight games against the Warriors - compelling stats there. They also welcome back some key forwards (Collins, Radley, Leniu) to bolster their middle. There was no fluke about their win last week and they'll be feeling better about themselves on the back of it. Rugby Union converts that succeed in the NRL are few and far between, but Nawaqanitawase could be an exception. Some lovely touches last week and he clearly has the size and strength to deliver. No changes for the Warriors seventeen that impressed against Manly last week. They're good enough, but the Chooks always seem to find a way against the Warriors.

Verdict – Roosters by 2

Brisbane Broncos vs North Queensland Cowboys – Friday night – Suncorp Stadium

It's been ten years (yes...really) since these sides met in what I call the best grand final I've ever seen. A point of controversy of course, but one thing is for certain, the derbies between these two rarely disappoint. The Cowboys have been fair to middling thus far this season, but a few significant inclusions (Taumalolo, Clifford, Nanai) should add some spark. Some tough games in the weeks ahead and there's some chance the Cowboys first points this season could be the Bye in round seven. A tough climb from there if that's the case. No changes for the Broncos seventeen - they were a little disappointing last week but the Raiders are going to do that to plenty of teams this season. The Cowboys have conceded 78 points in the first two rounds, and this Broncos backline has points in them. Walsh overplayed his hand last week, a habit his coach is no doubt trying to squeeze out of his game. Less is more, Reece. Less is more. I've heard that this game is sold out, but there's a sprinkling of tickets here and there. If you want one you might want to get on your bike. .

Verdict – Broncos by 10

Cronulla Sharks vs South Sydney Rabbitohs – Saturday afternoon – Sharks Stadium

The undefeated Rabbitohs get to test their mettle against a genuine contender on Saturday afternoon. Fortune has shone brightly on them thus far - a narrow win over the Dolphins who were distracted by the weather, followed by a narrow win over the Dragons, who scored more tries than the Bunnies but lost regardless. This is a step up in grade I think, and the Sharks will be keen to deliver in their first home game of the year. The return of Jack Wighton helps the visitors, but there's class across the paddock for the Sharks and they should get it done.

Verdict – Sharks by 7

Redcliffe Dolphins vs Wests Tigers – Saturday afternoon – Kayo Stadium

It hasn't been a great start for the Dolphins this season but they've had more disruption than anyone to contend with. This is their first home game of the year, and it's significant that they'll be playing in Redcliffe. Their home town has copped a fair battering and the club gets a chance to give the whole community a lift. Bostock and Finefeuiaki are back but neither have been named in the seventeen which is interesting. That may change before kick-off. No changes for the Tigers but Bula has a troublesome foot issue to overcome and he may be rested. Heath Mason has been named on an extended bench and would likely get the call up. The Tigers were solid against the Eels last week but I've made it clear how I feel about the Eels...this is harder.

Verdict – Dolphins by 4

Gold Coast Titans vs Newcastle Knights – Saturday night – Cbus Super Stadium

The first home game for the Titans who, much like the Dolphins, have had an interrupted start to the year. They'll be better prepared after the hit out against the Bulldogs last week. That said, conceding 40 points is a concern. The Knights are 2 from 2 and looking good. They aren't a one-man team but we all know they're a much more formidable opponent when Ponga is in form. The Knights have a very kind draw, and they're likely to be at or near the top of the ladder for the next few months. Some key omissions this weekend though, with Thompson and Pearce-Paul unavailable. That evens up the forwards battle, but the Knights have plenty of size in their backline (and the Titans don't). Bigger isn't always better, but I'm tipping the visitors in what should be a competitive high-scoring contest.

Verdict – Knights by 4

Parramatta Eels vs Canterbury Bulldogs – Sunday afternoon – CommBank Stadium

It's a shame the Eels are going so poorly, because they'd be packed to rafters if they were in any sort of form. It will still be a decent crowd, but there's some chance the visitors will have more supporters in the stands. Injuries to Burton and Kikau means the Bulldogs aren't certainties in this, but they're undefeated and travelling well. The Eels scored just the one try against the Tigers last week, and they didn't get that until the 79th minute. Their defence is worse - conceding 88 point across two games thus far. A long season ahead.

Verdict – Bulldogs by 10

Manly Sea Eagles vs Canberra Raiders – Sunday afternoon – 4 Pines Park

Manly lost their biggest supporter during the week. It's impossible to know how teams will respond to situations like these, but I'm hoping they get the job done, I'm hoping Turbo scores a try, and I'm hoping he finds a camera and gives us a 'That's Gold'. Should all that happen, I'll be a blubbering mess. I've added a video on the page for some context. RIP Beau.

Verdict – Sea Eagles by 10

Wally Lewis - round three selections (in bold)

Note: tips from Wally will be published on Wednesday night or Thursday morning

  • STORM vs Panthers
  • WARRIORS vs Roosters
  • BRONCOS vs Cowboys
  • SHARKS vs Rabbitohs
  • DOLPHINS vs Tigers
  • Titans vs KNIGHTS
  • Eels vs BULLDOGS
  • SEA EAGLES vs Raiders

A Visit from a Special Supporter

Comments

The Thinker's picture

Greetings football fans

I have updated the NRL ladder and the tipping comp after round two. Early rounds every season can be a raffle and 2025 looks no different, with plenty of upsets.

A special shout out to Chook_Dan - our only tipster who found the Roosters, which just might be the biggest upset of the season.

And another special shout out to our top tipster, Doobynuts, with a very impressive 6 from 8. Outstanding work.

And I won't name and shame them, but two of our former season tipping champions scored just 1 from 8 - an indication of just how tough it was.

As always, if anyone notices any issues with the scoring just let me know.

I'll have my previews and selections published on Wednesday.

All the best

The Thinker

Lochnesslaine's picture

Hi Thinker
In round 2 I picked Knights, Sharks, Tigers and Bulldogs so I had 4 correct tips not 3. When you get a chance can you please correct scoreboard.

Thank you

The Thinker's picture

@Lochnesslaine

Sorry about that.

Thanks for letting me know - I've updated your scores now.

All the best

The Thinker

Lochnesslaine's picture

Hi Thinker
No problem…..
😌

Bong's picture

Hey Mr Thinker,
Last rounds tips i was able to select however this round the link is not there, am i just to early or smth?

Cheers,
Bong🍃

The Thinker's picture

Hi Bong

As long as you have logged in (looks like you have based on your comment) the link to the tipping form should be there for you.

It appears just under a heading called 'Guest tips for this round'. You should see a bunch of icons for tipsters who have already put their tips in, and just below that there is a link called 'Show/Hide the tipping form'. Click that link...the pick your teams and make sure you click the submit button at the bottom.

Let me know how you go.

All the best

The Thinker

Bong's picture

I’m having the same problem as round one where the show hid tipping form is not there, might just have to comment them again,

Cheers,
BONG

Dragons-fanboy's picture

Hi all,

My tips for this week are:

Storm by 6
Roosters by 2
Broncos by 18
Sharks by 10
Tigers by 4
Titans by 4
Bulldogs by 24
Manly by 8

Good luck to everyone’s teams this week except us Dragons fans at least we will have some points on the board by the end of the week something to smile about at least hahahaha! Cheers!!!!!!

Footy chick's picture

OMG Thinker. That video. I'm a blubbering mess now.
Go Manly. Thoughts with Beau and his family and friends. xx

NONDO JIM's picture

HI ALL
CAN WE TRY OUR BEST TO ALEAST DO THE BEST TIPS PLEASE

Steel Panther's picture

Bloody nice touch with the video Thinker. Hard to watch with a dry eye, and certainly brings life into perspective. What a great kid. Thanks for posting!!

Rick's picture

Hi Thinker thank you for running the comp again this year and great video mate thank you for uploading it😊👍. Just to share with you I noticed you have the Eels instead of the Bulldogs in the "NRL tips at a glance" page for your own tips. Cheers.

The Thinker's picture

@Rick

Well spotted, and thanks for letting me know.

I've fixed that now.

All the best

The Thinker

tigerholic's picture

Hey Thinker
That video proved that Balmain Boys do cry, that kid is amazing how strong he is.

Steel Panther is right when he says it brings life into perspective, the small things we worry about and what we think are hard times, all you need to do is watch that video over and over.

Well done to the Manly players, obviously meant a lot to the kid.

Tiger

doobynuts's picture

Hi Thinker,

The link is not showing for me. I have tried several times on 2 different laptops but for some reason there is just an ad where the link should be.

My tips for round 3 are:

Storm
Warriors
Broncos
Sharks
Dolphins
Knights
Bulldogs
Raiders

Thanks, doobynuts

doobynuts's picture

Whoops found it. All good thanks

The Thinker's picture

@doobynuts

Thanks for perservering.

I've just gone in and tried to remove some of the ads on the site. It will take an hour or two for the changes to filter through. Hopefully it gets rid of some of the clutter.

All the best

The Thinker

NONDO JIM's picture

HOW ABOUT YOUR ROUND 2 TIPS

Gummy Sharks 's picture

Morning all. Away from home computer so I hope this works. Broncos in a’s competition and Storm, Warriors, Sharks, Tigers, Titans, Bulldogs, Raiders please.

NONDO JIM's picture

ANY ROUND 2 TIPS

The Thinker's picture

@NONDO JIM

You're living in the past - we are already up to round three.

But if you want them, here were my round two tips

All the best

The THinker

MGM's picture

I have a confession to make.
I don't really know very much about rugby league.
I can't even figure out where numbers 2, 3, 4, and 5 belong on the field!
What are their positions ?
It seems to depend on which team they are playing for.

It's really stuffing up my "anytime try scorer" bets.
Match reviewers often refer to a team as having a notoriously weak left edge , for example. .... so I include their oppositions no5 in my multi and only to discover during the match that no5 is playing outside no3 on his team's Left Edge!
The lesson here is "don't bet on a game you clearly know nothing about"!
.... Oh , and "Gamble Responsibly" boys and girls ... :-)

MGM's picture

Hiya Gummy.
You have only given Thinker seven selections for His comp.
I'm sure you intended your selection for a's comp to carry over to this one , but you're a very tall poppy at the top of our ladder right now .... watch out for the "pedants"!

Thinker , maybe an email to Gummy might be necessary if he's away from his home computer as he says.

a's picture

He said broncos in the a comp

MGM's picture

Duh !

TigerGirl's picture

Melbourne
NZ
Brisbane
Sharks
West Tigers
Newcastle
Bulldogs
Manly
The form is gone again. 7.13pm here in NSW

Ellelicious2707's picture

Hi Thinker

I was unable to find the tipping page for round 3, I have left my tips as below:

Panthers
Roosters
Broncos
Sharks
Tigers
Knights
Bulldogs
Raiders

Thank you,

The Thinker's picture

Hi all

If you can't see the tipping form and game one hasn't started yet, just add your tips in the comments and I will add them in.

Daylight savings strikes again.

All the best

The Thinker

@TigerGirl and Ellelicious2707

Will do

GOTTAKICKSTRAIGHT's picture

RD 3 Picks
storm
roosters
broncos
sharks
tigers
knights
dogs
eagles

Majordad's picture

Hi Thinker could not get my tips on ,they are storm,warriors,broncos,sharks,dolphins,knights,bulldogs and raiders,,,thanks

The Last Samurai's picture

Hi Thinker
Sorry ads are totally blocking tipping sheet.
I have made one change to Titans. I think that went through
Can you change my other selection to Raiders as i carnt get through.
Regards The Last Samurai

Bronco Legend's picture

Hi Thinker can't do my tips so have to do them here.
Storm
Roosters
Broncs
Sharks
Tiges
Knights
Dogs
Eagles
Not sure whats happened

Essere il Capo's picture

Hi Thinker
Round 3 tips
Storm
New Zealand Warriors
Brisbane
Sharks
Dolphins
Titans
Bulldogs
Canberra
Will accept judges descion.

Gummy Sharks 's picture

Broncos as well please if that’s allowed. Thanks MGM and a.

Chook_Dan's picture

If only I could tip upsets like that every week!

Mary S's picture

Hi MGM,
I've read your comments, have seen your pick for "a" 3 strike comp, but I haven't seen your tips yet for R3!!!

Not too late to add the rest in the comments.

Cheers,
Mary

MGM's picture

Hi Thinker , Hi Mary ,
Thinker this is two weeks in a row now and I'm 100% positive that I entered my tips on the tipping form/link this week.
I don't get the ads that others have complained about, so something strange is going on.
I clicked the link and entered them around 7:10pm and saw your comment at 7:19pm that "Daylight savings strikes again", which confused me because you are an hour behind us, not in front.
No irony to be amused by this week either ... my tips were :
Storm
Warriors
Broncos
Sharks
Dolphins
Knights
Bulldogs
Eagles

The Thinker's picture

Greetings football fans

I believe I have everyone's tips in the system. If anyone notices anything that still needs tweaking just let me know.

All the best

The Thinker

p.s. still trying to remove more ads :-)

Mary S's picture

Hi Thinker

The Colonel had his tips entered in the 3 strike comp. section -

"Submitted by The Colonel on Thu 20/3/25 - 6:44pm AEST

Haven't been able to find the guest tips, again. Round 3 mine are:
Storm
Warriors
Broncos
Sharks
West Tigers
Knights
Bulldogs
Sea Eagles"

Cheers,
Mary

The Thinker's picture

@Mary S

Thanks so much for that

I've added The Colonel now.

All the best

The Thinker

MGM's picture

Thankyou Thinker, thankyou Mary.
I Will be double checking that my icon has appeared along with the others from now on.
Good luck to all for round three , especially the Dolphins fans!

bradapple's picture

Up the wahs guys!!

Mary S's picture

bradapple -They did you proud!!!

Cheers,
Mary

Rocket Ryan's picture

Lots of problems at the Dolphins
Attitudes need reshaping too many star players to be serving up the rubbish we saw today.

bradapple's picture

@Rocket Ryan I'd have to agree, Hammer just jogged around all game.

tigerholic's picture

Rocket
The Tigers were simply the better team on the day.

Tiger

Add new comment

The latest in NRL news